MCK: 2018 Annual Meeting / Notice of Meeting
MILLENNIUM & COPTHORNE HOTELS NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
NOTICE OF ANNUAL MEETING OF SHAREHOLDERS
Notice is given that the Annual Meeting of Millennium & Copthorne Hotels New Zealand Limited (“the Company”) will be held at the Catalyst 4 Room, M
Social Auckland, 196-200 Quay Street, Auckland, New Zealand, on Thursday 31 May 2018 commencing at 2.00pm.
BUSINESS
Chairman’s Welcome & Introduction
Managing Director’s Review
Resolutions
1 To elect director
In accordance with the Company’s Constitution, Colin SIM,
having been appointed by the Board after the last annual
meeting of shareholders, retires and offers himself for election.
(See Explanatory Notes for profile)
2 To re-elect director
In accordance with the Company’s Constitution, Richard
BOBB retires by rotation and, being eligible, offers himself for
re-election.
(See Explanatory Notes for profile)
3 To re-elect director
In accordance with the Company’s Constitution, Kevin
HANGCHI retires by rotation and, being eligible, offers himself
for re-election.
(See Explanatory Notes for profile)
4 Auditors’ remuneration
To consider and, if thought fit, pass the following resolution as
an ordinary resolution:
“That the Board of Directors be authorised to fix the
auditors’ fees and expenses”.
(See Explanatory Notes for more information)
5. Shareholder Proposal – Special dividend and payment to
staff and directors
Mr. Howard Zingel, a shareholder, has proposed the following
resolution to consider and, if thought fit, pass as an ordinary
resolution:
“I move that shareholders vote in favour of asking the
Directors to pay a special dividend of 10 cents per share by
the end of 2018, that at the same time those staff members
who have served the Company for more than a year, at that
date, be paid $1,000.00 each and the Directors also at that
date be awarded $5,000.00 each”
THE BOARD DOES NOT SUPPORT THIS NON-BINDING
RESOLUTION (See Explanatory Notes for more information
from Mr. Zingel and from the Board in response to this
proposal)
General Business
By Order of the Board
Boon Pua
Vice President Finance & Company Secretary
14 May 2018
2
PROCEDURAL NOTES
Proxies and Corporate Representatives
Shareholders entitled to attend and vote at the Annual Meeting may appoint a proxy or representative (in the case of a corporate shareholder) to attend
and vote on their behalf. A proxy need not be a shareholder of the Company. The Chairman of the meeting, or any other director, is willing to act as
proxy for any shareholder who wishes to appoint him to vote on their behalf. To appoint the Chairman of the meeting or another director as your proxy,
enter 'the Chairman' or the name of that other director you wish to appoint in the space allocated in 'Step 1' of the proxy form enclosed with this Notice.
Proxy forms must be received at the office of the Company’s share registrar, Computershare Investor Services Limited, 159 Hurstmere Road, Takapuna
or Private Bag 92119, Auckland 1142, New Zealand (or fax +64 (9) 488-8787) by 2.00pm on Tuesday 29 May 2018. An instrument appointing a proxy
is enclosed with this Notice.
All resolutions are ordinary resolutions and must be passed by a simple majority of the votes of those shareholders entitled to vote and voting on the
resolutions.
In accordance with section 109(3) of the Companies Act 1993, resolution 5 (if passed) will not be binding on the Board or the Company.
EXPLANATORY NOTES
Resolution 1 - Election of director:
Colin SIM
Mr. Sim was appointed to the Board effective from 14 July 2017 as an independent non-executive director and was elected as Chairman of MCK in
August 2017. As he was appointed by the Board after the last annual meeting of shareholders, under the Company’s Constitution he is required to retire
and offer himself for election at this annual meeting. The Board has determined that Mr. Sim is an Independent Director as defined under the NZX Main
Board Listing Rules.
Mr Sim is the executive chairman of the East Quarter Group of companies (East Quarter Hurstville, EQ Projects and EQ Constructions) (EQ) in
Australia. EQ is currently involved in the development and construction of residential units across New South Wales. Mr. Sim has strong analytical
skills and extensive experience in construction and property development/investment in Australia. In the last four decades he has also been involved
in takeovers of several large publicly listed companies in Australia, including Wormald, Hooker Corporation, Enacon and Hastings Deering. Mr. Sim
studied Mechanical Engineering in London and has lived in Sydney, Australia for the last 40 years.
The Board unanimously recommends shareholders vote in favour of the election of Mr Sim.
Resolution 2 – Re-election of director:
Richard BOBB
Mr. Bobb is a Chartered Accountant with over thirty-five years’ experience. He is currently a member of the Professional Conduct Tribunal of the Institute
of Chartered Accountants in Australia and was a member of New South Wales Joint State Taxes Committee of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in
Australia and the CPA Australia. He was also a member and past Chairman of the Joint Legislation Review Committee and a member and past Chairman
of the Legislation Review Board of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in Australia and the CPA Australia. He is admitted as a Barrister in New South
Wales. The Board has determined that Mr. Bobb is an Independent Director as defined under the NZX Main Board Listing Rules.
Mr. Bobb was last re-elected to the Board at the 2016 annual meeting of shareholders.
The Board unanimously recommends shareholders vote in favour of the re-election of Mr Bobb.
Resolution 3 – Re-election of director:
Kevin HANGCHI
Mr. Hangchi is currently Senior Vice President, Hong Leong Management Services Pte. Limited. He has global transactional experience across many
of the Hong Leong Group’s entities including listings and public offerings, mergers and acquisitions as well as capital markets issuances and banking
facilities. Mr. Hangchi has been called to the English and Singaporean bars and holds an honours degree in Accountancy and Law from the University
of Southampton.
Mr. Hangchi was elected to the Board at the 2016 annual meeting of shareholders.
The Board unanimously recommends shareholders vote in favour of the re-election of Mr Hangchi.
Resolution 4 - Auditors’ remuneration:
KPMG are the existing Auditors of the Company. KPMG are automatically reappointed as Auditors under section 207T of the Companies Act 1993.
Section 207S of the Companies Act 1993 provides that the fees and expenses of the auditor are to be fixed in such manner as the Company determines
at the annual meeting. The Board recommends that, consistent with usual practice, the auditor’s fees and expenses be fixed by the Directors.
The Board unanimously recommends shareholders vote in favour of this resolution.
Resolution 5 – Shareholder Proposal – Special Dividend and payment to staff and directors:
Mr. Howard Zingel, an MCK shareholder, has provided the following additional information in support of his resolution:
“Company statics vary considerably; nevertheless market commentators give a median P.E of 17.5 to the NZ share market.
3
P.E being the share price to earnings ratio. More simply the number of years it would take for earnings per share in cents to equal the
current share price.
At a share price of 285 cents and historic earnings of 27.25 cents per share the MCK PE ratio is 10.5. A lower than median ratio means
investors generally rate the share poorly. The greater the deviation to the median, the more poorly viewed. A significant issue for MCK is
the low dividend pay-out ; most easily measured by the times dividend ratio. In the case of MCK it is 4.5 times against a market norm of
less than 2. In other words our dividend is less than half what investors would normally expect
It is acknowledged there are many considerations which go to make investor opinion. Earnings quality and transparency amongst many.
MCK is in a sweet spot and the Chairman is promising a swift move towards modern governance.
In this felicitous state, shareholders require an enhanced dividend and at the same time wish to share the good fortune with other
stakeholders.”
MCK’s Board has considered the proposed resolution and responds as follows:
In accordance with section 109(3) of
the Companies Act 1993, resolution 5, if passed, will NOT be binding on the Board or the Company.
Section 109(2) of the Companies Act provides that a meeting of shareholders may pass a resolution relating to the management of the
company. However, section 109(3) provides that a resolution passed pursuant to section 109(2) is not binding unless the constitution provides
that such a resolution is binding. The Company’s constitution does not provide for such a resolution to be binding. Accordingly, as each of
the three elements of the proposed resolution (payment of a special dividend, a payment to staff and a payment to directors) relate to the
management of the Company, the resolution (if passed) will not be binding on the Board or the Company.
While the Board appreciates the sentiment that Mr. Zingel is expressing regarding making a bonus payment to staff and the directors in
recognition of their contribution to the Company’s recent performance, the Board does not believe that his proposal is justified.
The Board believes that the Company should maintain sufficient cash and other financial resources to ensure that it is able to meet its current
and future requirements. This year, MCK acquired the Millennium Hotel New Plymouth Waterfront and the Company is looking to expand its
network within New Zealand with suitable properties provided that they meet its investment criteria. The Board therefore does not consider
it is an appropriate time to pay a special dividend and these payments would impose a significant cost on the Company.
The Board also believes that price / equity ratio (PE) is only one metric that may be considered in relation to a Company’s dividend policy
and performance. MCK’s policy is to pay shareholders a percentage of net profit after tax, with the current percentage being around 25 to
30 percent. The dividend paid out has increased by over four times since 2013.
The Board does not consider it is appropriate to pay the proposed bonus payments to staff and the directors. While appreciating the efforts
of staff, the Board believes that the Company’s current remuneration policy (which includes scope for bonus payments for extraordinary
performance) is appropriate. In relation to the directors’ remuneration, the Board acknowledges that the pool for directors’ fees has not been
increased since 1996. In the near future the Board intends to review its current remuneration levels and will seek approval from shareholders
under NZX Main Board Listing Rule 3.5.1 if it believes that an increase in the pool for directors’ fees is appropriate in light of that review.
The Board does NOT support this resolution and unanimously recommends that shareholders vote against it.
Data sourced from publicly available filings. Our datasets may not be complete. Automated analysis can produce errors. If you believe any data on this page is incorrect, please contact us at hello@nzxplorer.co.nz. For informational purposes only. Not investment advice.
Other issuers discussed similar conditions around this time
Matched by meaning across NZX announcement text, not keywords — based on our semantic index of announcement bodies.
- CDI — CDL Investments New Zealand Limited: CDI: 2018 Annual Meeting / Notice of Meeting2018-05-14
“1 CDL INVESTMENTS NEW ZEALAND LIMITED NOTICE OF ANNUAL MEETING OF SHAREHOLDERS Notice is given that the Annual Meeting of CDL Investments New Zealand Limited (“the Company”) will be held at Catalyst 4 Room, M Social Auckland, 196-200 Quay Street, Auckland, New…”
- NZM — NZME Limited: NZME 2018 Notice of Annual Shareholders’ Meeting2018-05-24
“2018 NOTICE OF ANNUAL MEETING NZME Central iHeart Lounge, 2-4 Graham Street, Auckland Commencing at 3:00pm (NZT), Thursday 21 June 2018 23 Dear Shareholder, NZME Limited (NZME) invites you to join us for our Annual Shareholders’ Meeting. The meeting will be held on Thursday…”
- AFC — AFC Group Holdings Limited: Notice of Annual Meeting and Proxy Voting Form2018-08-12
“5. Resolution 3: Fixing the Fees and Expenses of the auditor To record that shareholder authorise the directors to fix the fees and expenses of the auditor for the financial year ending 31 March 2019 pursuant to section 200 of the Companies Act 1993 and to consider, and if tho…”