Chorus’ annual shareholders’ meeting
Chorus Limited
Level 10, 1 Willis Street
P O Box 632
Wellington 6140
New Zealand
Email:company.secretary@chorus.co.nz
STOCK EXCHANGE ANNOUNCEMENT
31 October 2019
Chorus’ annual shareholders’ meeting
The attached prepared announcements will be delivered at Chorus’ annual
shareholders’ meeting to be held in Wellington at 10.30am today:
Chairman’s address;
CEO’s address; and
Presentation slides.
Copies of these announcements will be available on Chorus’ website later today.
The meeting will also be webcast live on the investor section of Chorus’ website at
www.chorus.co.nz/webcast.
ENDS
For further information:
Nathan Beaumont
Stakeholder Communications Manager
Phone +64 4 896 4352
Mobile: +64 21 243 8412
Email: Nathan.Beaumont@chorus.co.nz
Brett Jackson
Investor Relations Manager
Phone: +64 4 896 4039
Mobile: +64 27 488 7808
Email: Brett.Jackson@chorus.co.nz
---
Chorus Annual Meeting 31 October 2019
Chair’s Address
Good morning and welcome to Chorus’ 2019 Annual Shareholders
Meeting. It is great to see some familiar faces back, and thank you for
making the effort to join us today.
My name is Patrick Strange and I am Chorus’ chair.
Our agenda this morning is a short address from me. We’ll then hear from
chief executive Kate McKenzie, followed by resolutions and voting.
My fellow directors are here today:
Jon Hartley, Deputy Chair
Prue Flacks
Anne Urlwin
Murray Jordan
Mark Cross
Jack Matthews
and, of course
Kate McKenzie.
We also have our Chief Financial Officer, David Collins, General Counsel &
Company Secretary, Elaine Campbell, several other key executives, and
our auditors KPMG here with us today.
During the financial year ended 30 June, Chorus achieved a net profit of
$53 million and EBITDA of $636 million, in line with guidance.
This enabled us to deliver a fully imputed dividend of 23 cents per share
this financial year. This is anticipated to increase to 24 cents per share in
FY20, subject to no material adverse changes in circumstance or outlook.
In the board's view this represents a prudent dividend policy that reflects
our current operating environment.
We had a strong year for broadband connections, with an increase of
9,000 lines, despite expected losses in the LFC areas as they install fibre
to our copper customers. This was a significant jump from a gain of just
1,000 broadband lines in FY18 and reflects our ongoing initiatives to win
broadband customers from cable and fixed wireless networks in our own
fibre areas, together with growth in the number of premises nationwide.
We’re about 80% of the way to our target of building our fibre network
past approximately 1.36 million homes and businesses by the end of
2022. And under UFB2 (an extension to the original UFB rollout), we’ve
started taking fibre to more than 300 smaller towns for the extension of
(UFB2), where fibre promises to deliver even greater socio-economic
benefits.
Unquestionably, the Ultra-Fast Broadband programme has been a success
for New Zealand inc. Infrastructure NZ has called it one of the most
successful Public Private Partnerships in New Zealand’s history.
With the first phase of the programme nearing completion in the coming
weeks, it is important to celebrate and recognise what the team has
achieved.
It’s a great example of how Government and the private sector can work
in partnership to deliver a step change in infrastructure quality on behalf
of the country. It’s a model that could be used to solve many other
infrastructure investment challenges.
But while the UFB is nearing completion, there are a number of other
large New Zealand infrastructure projects that must get underway in the
coming years. We all know the problem - recent Treasury figures indicated
that some NZ$130b needs to be invested over the next 10 years to get
New Zealand’s infrastructure up to scratch to meet significant population
growth and ever increasing demands.
At least part of that funding will need to be raised from private investors,
not unlike the Chorus model. So New Zealand’s attractiveness to investors
both locally and, most importantly, internationally will underpin the
country’s ability to deliver this unprecedented infrastructure programme.
A key signal to potential investors about the risks of investment in New
Zealand infrastructure will be the Commerce Commission’s
implementation of the regime that will govern the new fibre broadband
network built by Chorus.
These international investors (including many of our current shareholders)
are watching the Chorus regulatory process very closely. If they sense
that they are not going to get a fair return for the multi-billion dollar
investment they made, a return that reflects the considerable risk they
took and the long period they have waited for a return, this will be the last
investment they and their investment community will make in New
Zealand infrastructure - they have choices about where they put their
money, and we are competing with other nations for it.
So their experience with Chorus will have a huge impact on New Zealand’s
ability to deliver the next $130 billion of essential infrastructure, cost
effectively, for everyone.
We will continue to work constructively with the Commission, providing
high quality information and open engagement to allow them to reach the
right solutions in as timely and thorough manner as possible.
Another area of strong focus for Chorus is customer experience. It is no
secret that the huge, un-forecast, early take-up of fibre by New
Zealanders stretched our capacity in early years. And some customers
experienced delays and frustrations as a result. For our part, we have
made significant strides in improving the fibre installation process,
delivering record volumes and new highs in customer experience. We are
not perfect, but most customers have a prompt, effective installation now
- and virtually every customer loves the speed, quality and reliability fibre
offers.
But a challenge the whole telecommunications industry faces is
communicating offerings in a way that customers want and understand.
Put simply, too often we still see big promises made and experience that
doesn’t quite measure up. We’ve also seen examples of people being sold
broadband services that they didn’t really understand.
As a sector we need to do better on this. New Zealanders are already
wary of telecommunications – with low levels of trust and lots of
complaints at RSP level.
And we’ve seen what happens in other sectors such as banking when
conduct issues undermine consumer trust.
We all have to do better, and take the long term health of the whole
sector into account through much greater customer focus.
Chorus will do our part, ensuring we provide easily understandable and
trustworthy information about our products that allow customers to make
clear and realistic comparisons. We hope others will do the same - and
will not hesitate to call out instances where this is not happening,
something we have been reluctant to do up to now.
Finally, those of you who were here last year will recall that I addressed
the allegations of mistreatment of some individuals within our sub-
contracted field force and committed to getting those issues sorted out,
including commissioning an independent review. The issues arose
principally within our migrant work force - whose contribution has been
key to delivering the build in a period where labour has impossible to
source locally.
We completed that independent review, and published it in its entirety.
We have now completed a six month programme of work as a first step in
an ongoing fundamental shift in management of our supply chain.
We have audited all sub-contracting companies, which resulted in 38 sub-
contractors ceasing work on the Chorus network, and more than 100 more
committing to improving.
Along with Visionstream and UCG, we have also:
Developed worker’s rights roadshows and new training for sub-
contractors and their employees
Finalised a new independent whistle-blower process
Improved the fairness of how jobs are allocated and paid for
Put lots of other structural improvements in place.
Chorus is absolutely committed to making the changes needed to make
this right. We remain open to further changes if monitoring does not show
all the improvements we want to see.
In terms of key personnel, the Board continues to evolve and refresh.
Anne Urlwin, who is a founding director, having been on the Board since
Chorus’ establishment in 2011, is standing down this year.
Anne steps down with the very best wishes of the rest of the Board and
our thanks for her hard work, insights and very valuable contribution to
Chorus. She will be missed.
We are pleased to have Sue Bailey standing for election to the Chorus
Board today. Sue has spent her career in the telecommunications market,
working for high profile companies such as Telstra, Virgin Mobile
Australia/Virgin Mobile USA, and most recently for Optus where she was a
member of the executive leadership team.
The Board unanimously supports Sue’s appointment as an independent
director, believing she will bring strong new experience and capabilities to
the Board.
We are also very pleased that Mark Cross is standing for re-election as a
Chorus director. Mark is standing due to the NZX listing rules
requirements that require existing directors to retire and stand for re-
election every three years. Mark will replace Anne as Chair of our Audit
and Risk Committee, and is currently chair of Milford Asset Management,
MFL Mutual Fund and Superannuation Investments, and a director of Z
Energy.
The Board unanimously supports Mark’s appointment as an independent
director.
Finally, Chorus will also move forward with new management leadership
as Kate McKenzie is stepping down as CEO.
On behalf of the Board, I would like to thank Kate for the superb work she
has done leading Chorus. Chorus is well placed to take advantage of the
opportunities ahead as we move from building the fibre network to
operating it, thanks to her tenure and leadership.
We are sorry to see her go but understand her desire to spend more time
with her Sydney-based family. She will leave with our very best wishes
and thanks for a job well done.
In terms of Kate’s replacement, we announced a couple of weeks ago that
JB Rousselot will take over as CEO on 20 November 2019.
JB previously held senior positions at Telstra and NBN Co. Most recently
he was Chief Strategy Officer at NBN, and before that he oversaw NBN’s
network and service operations.
The Board was fortunate to be able to consider several high-quality
candidates for the role, and we are pleased to have secured JB to lead
Chorus through the next phase of its evolution. And he inherits a very
high performing executive team from Kate, so the company will not miss a
beat.
I will now hand over to Kate to take you through some more detail about
the work she and the team are doing.
Thank you.
---
Chorus Annual Meeting 31 October 2019
CEO’s Address
Tena koutou katoa
Thank you Patrick and good morning everyone.
A special welcome in particular to those of you who have joined us here in
our offices today - I look forward to talking to you after the meeting.
It’s wonderful to be able to update you today on how Chorus is
performing, not just in terms of our New Zealand operations, but also
within a broader global context.
I’ve just returned from the Broadband World Forum in Europe, where
global network operators and vendors share their views on broadband
developments and trends.
In the space of a few years, technology discussions at the conference
have swung from focusing on ways to extend the life of copper to a
recognition that fibre is without question the best possible broadband
technology.
The European telco operators we met with would give their eye teeth to
have our fibre network. A rollout more than 80% complete, on time and
on budget, with uptake already surpassing 55% in our fibre areas is still a
distant dream for many.
Recent industry research from IDC suggested New Zealand’s fibre
adoption rate is more than double the average worldwide rate, and second
only to Japan, with 44% of New Zealand consumers primarily accessing
the internet through a fibre connection.
Of course the obstacles to rolling out fibre vary from country to country.
They boil down to things like the practical challenges of building fibre in
city environments, as well as regulatory and political hurdles. Together,
these factors determine whether there is a business case for investing in
fibre.
New Zealand has shown how a public private partnership can solve that
business case and deliver an extremely cost effective outcome for
taxpayers.
Some of the few telco operators that have made the leap to fibre are now
also beginning to quantify the operational benefits. In Portugal, for
example, fibre uptake is over 40% and the copper network has started to
be phased out by network operator Altice. They are seeing faults and
maintenance costs reduce significantly, along with electricity
requirements.
We’ve begun to see some of these benefits as fibre uptake grows, with
network maintenance costs reducing by 14% in FY19.
Our goal of reducing our greenhouse gas emissions by 80%, between
2012 and 2030, are closely linked to the reductions in operational and
electricity requirements that fibre enables.
Another factor that is giving impetus to the international business case for
fibre is data demand.
In the almost three years I’ve been at Chorus, average monthly data
demand has gone from 123 gigabytes to 279 Gigabytes. Fibre customers
are averaging 360 gigabytes a month.
This is not peculiar to New Zealand. European networks all cite average
usage similar to ours and they expect it to keep growing.
In Iceland, a fibre network providing 1 gigabit connections as a standard
broadband plan is now recording 500 Gigabytes a month average usage.
As we’ve seen with the Rugby World Cup, the growing consumer adoption
of video on demand services drives significant growth in data usage.
That’s all the more so when people watch live events online.
We invested in extra capacity ahead of the Rugby World Cup and it was
clearly needed. Record peak network throughput was about 2 terabits per
second before the tournament. It peaked at 2.6 terabits during the France
versus Wales quarterfinal.
The impending launch of online gaming services – like Google stadia – is
only going to fuel the demand for data further. Industry observers say
cloud gaming will almost double backhaul capacity requirements because
of the need for symmetric upload and download.
Interestingly, Vodafone Australia’s new chief information officer predicted
just the other week that data use will grow between 700 to 1,000 times
over the next five years. These predictions and the data trends we’re
already seeing may explain why there has been a noticeable reduction in
the international hype about 5G.
The industry is grappling with the business case for 5G investment, with
most operators seeming to focus on enterprise or private networks as the
primary use cases.
Some European operators are also turning to alternative network
investment solutions to bridge the investment hurdle. These include
selling off their tower assets, or entering into network sharing
arrangements.
We’re keeping a close eye on these international developments because
we believe infrastructure sharing at a wholesale level makes good
economic sense for New Zealand.
For example, we’ve begun trialling small cell deployments with mobile
operators, building on the success of earlier innovation trials to identify
alternative uses for our assets.
Indeed, much of the discussion at Broadband World Forum was about the
extent to which 5G will be reliant on fibre backhaul. One industry
commentator said 5G networks need 16 times more fibre than 4G
required.
And fibre just keeps getting better.
We have 10 Gigabit trials live today with a commercial product in the
works. Equipment vendors are developing capability for 25 Gig.
These kinds of speeds may sound extreme, but it wasn’t that long ago
that we thought 30 megabits was a lot.
That became 50 megabits.
Now technology vendors like Huawei suggest that 4K TV content needs
speeds of more than 80 megabits, while 8K will need more than 260
megabits and less than 15 milliseconds in latency.
With many homes having more than one screen or device operating at
any one time, this means the case for wider adoption of Gigabit plans is
already looking more and more compelling.
We’re already at 11% uptake of 1 gigabit plans, with more than 70,000
connections. And about 15% of orders are for 1 gigabit speeds.
Another consistent theme across global network operators is the need to
transform as technology changes and markets evolve. Ours is a dynamic
industry and themes like agility and collaboration are an increasingly
common language.
When I hear other operators discussing the challenges they face in getting
their teams to work together and make rapid changes, I’m very proud of
what we’ve achieved at Chorus in the last few years.
We’ve revamped our vision and values, with an emphasis on better
managing the changes we need to make as Chorus moves from a focus on
building fibre to maintaining and operating the fibre network. That has
entailed thinking more about the future skills and capability we require, as
we simplify and streamline our business.
This work is already paying off, as we use digital tools and machine
learning to improve our processes.
Initiatives like fibre in a day, where we pre-qualify homes in our network
systems for a single installation visit, mean we’re now connecting people
to fibre faster than ever.
In the three months to the end of September we completed 53,000 fibre
installations – our most ever, and we achieved it with about 670 field
crews.
And we lifted customer satisfaction. We went from 7.5 out of ten in July
last year to 7.8 by the end of September. That has been held back by
some variability between retailers, and scores are higher again where
customers are part of our fibre in a day process.
We’ve been pleased to see a lift in positive feedback on the connection
process appearing online as we’ve implemented the new process.
But, when we’re connecting tens of thousands of customers a month, we
also make mistakes. When that happens and we’re made aware of the
problem we apologise to the customer and then we make it right.
We’re also working on new ways to improve other aspects of the customer
experience on fibre.
This includes using digital channels to help retailers, service companies
and customers, gain much greater visibility of our network status,
availability and provisioning. Our goal is a virtuous circle of improved
customer experience with faster resolution of faults, retailers avoiding
unnecessary cost, and our technician workforce being more productive.
Another aspect of our business that’s starting to show real results is our
active wholesaler strategy. We’ve put a lot of effort into understanding
customer segments and connection trends across our network, and that’s
helped us undertake a range of targeted initiatives to grow fibre uptake.
We were delighted to see broadband uptake grow by 10,000 connections
in the first quarter. We added a record 46,000 fibre connections. Much of
that growth is in Auckland, where we’ve just completed the fibre rollout
and fibre now accounts for 72% of our broadband connections.
Together, solid broadband uptake and slowing disconnections in other
fibre company areas meant we enjoyed our best quarter for fixed line
connections in a good many years. That trend has continued through
October.
This doesn’t mean we’re going to take our eye off the ball. We know we
need to keep promoting fibre uptake and ensure that fibre delivers the
experience customers expect.
That’s why we are early adopters of new fibre terminals in the home that
include in-built wi-fi capability. Wi-fi performance can vary considerably
today depending on the quality of gateway devices and their set-up, so
we’re exploring how we might `improve that for consumers.
Devices with new more powerful wifi capability – called wifi6 – are also
close to being commercially available. WiFi6 uses 5G technologies to
deliver higher speeds and capacity, and we envisage it playing a key role
in enabling the convergence of fixed and mobile networks.
Farewell
It’s been my privilege to lead Chorus through a chapter in its
extraordinary journey.
I’m confident that during my time we’ve definitely made New Zealand
better and the company is well positioned to keep adapting into the
future.
As Patrick has noted, there’s still some unfinished business related to
bedding-in the regulatory regime. Although I couldn’t stretch my stay to
fit that additional two-year instalment, I trust the Commerce Commission
will adequately recognise the risks that investors took on to deliver such
great broadband for New Zealand consumers.
Europe is trying to attract investment to build a gigabit society. New
Zealand already has one.
When I head back over the Tasman Sea later this month, I certainly hope
to be telling anyone who’ll listen how New Zealand created a public-
partnership model the rest of the world should follow.
---
31 October 2019
ANNUAL MEETING
Agenda
>Chairman’s Introduction & Address
>CEO Address
>Resolutions
>Shareholder Discussion & Questions
>Morning tea
31 October 2019
ANNUAL MEETING
2
31 October 2019
ANNUAL MEETING
Your Board
3
31 October 2019
FY19 results overview
ANNUAL MEETING
4
31 October 2019
UFB context: A public-private partnership
Chorus was required to split from Telecom to build the UFB network and took on extensive
contractual obligations, as well as substantial project and other related risks. The “fair bet”
that investors took was an expectation of a fair return reflecting these risks.
In return, New Zealanders now have access to a world-leading fibre network at reasonable
cost, well ahead of when it might otherwise have been built and with limited public
investment.
Crown contracts required:
•split of Chorus from Telecom
•Chorus to have investment grade rating (with
dividend stopper if falls below)
•contracted product pricing, set by Crown to
ensure initial uptake and limited for 10 years
•stringent rollout requirements, including material
damages
•management step-in rights for material breach
•limitations on ongoing copper network investment
5
ANNUAL MEETING
31 October 2019
Lifting productivity and customer experience
FY19: 186,000 fibre installations
ANNUAL MEETING
installation crews reduced from 800 to 670
lifted customer satisfaction from 7.5 to 7.7
lead times down from 13 business days to 8
days
6
524
615
800
670
No. of crews:
31 October 2019
ANNUAL MEETING
Independent workforce review
Report released in April
7
All sub-contracting companies audited
Developed worker’s rights roadshows and new
training for sub-contractors and their
employees
Finalised a new independent whistle-blower
process
Improved the fairness of how jobs are allocated
and paid for
Other structural improvements
31 October 2019
ANNUAL MEETING
Director and CEO changes
Sue BaileyJB Rousselot
8
CEO Address
31 October 2019
ANNUAL MEETING
31 October 2019
ANNUAL MEETING
10
▪We expect our investment in fibreto help us achieve an 80%
reduction in our scope 1 and 2 greenhouse gas emissions, from
our FY12 base year, by 2030.
▪Our investment in FTTH is also enhancing our network resiliency
for climate-related events. We consider the potential near to
medium term financial impact of climate change effects on our
business to be low.
31 October 201911
Making New Zealand better
ANNUAL MEETING
1,000 Gigabytes per month by 2023...
Video content and 4K, 8K to drive usage growth
31 October 2019
Application requirements in Mbps
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
June 2019June 2020June 2021June 2022June 2023June 2024
Chorus forecast: average monthly
broadband usage (GB)
CopperFibre
GB
Source: Cisco VNI, Forecast and Trends, 2017-2022
12
ANNUAL MEETING
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Jun-18Sep-18Dec-18Mar-19Jun-19Sep-19
% of
plans
Total mass market fibre uptake by plan type
50Mbps
100Mbps
1Gbps
31 October 2019
Gigabit society and beyond
200Mbps
$60 p.m.
$46 p.m.
$42.50 p.m.
$55 p.m.
Business/Education plans
13
ANNUAL MEETING
10G PON in trial, 25G PON on the roadmap
Source: Nokia
31 October 2019
ANNUAL MEETING
14
31 October 2019
ANNUAL MEETING
Working together to improve customer experience
Customers like our new installation process
“...noticed that fibre is available at my address and I called
2degrees on Sunday afternoon to switch over...The router
arrived on Tuesday morning and at lunch time the chorus guys
came and asking if I wannaconnect it a same day ,then they just
carried on their work and voila! 3 hours later Fibre is all up and
running.”
“Had pretty much same with BigPipe, router arrived pretty much
day after I signed up, few days later Chorus were onsite and
completed the install same day. Was so surprised I got caught up
with my bill for previous ISP”
Source: Geekzonewebsite
15
Chorus fibreuptake
31 October 2019
ANNUAL MEETING
16
Fibrenow 65% of broadband in UFB zone
72% of Auckland broadband
connections now on fibre
-
100,000
200,000
300,000
400,000
500,000
600,000
700,000
800,000
900,000
1,000,000
Chorus UFB zone broadband mix
FTTPCopper broadband
72
15
13
Auckland broadband connections
by type (%)
Fibre
Copper - VDSL
Copper - ADSL
31 October 2019
ANNUAL MEETING
17
Resolutions
31 October 2019
ANNUAL MEETING
31 October 2019
Resolutions
ANNUAL MEETING
1.That Mr Mark Cross be re-elected as a Chorus director.
2. That Ms Sue Bailey be elected as a Chorus director.
3. That the maximum aggregate remuneration able to be paid to all directors (in
their capacity as directors) be increased by $19,542 (1.7%) from $1,149,500 to
$1,169,042 per annum.
4. That the Board be authorised to fix the fees and expenses of KPMG as auditor.
5. That Chorus’ constitution be altered in the form and manner described in
Explanatory Note 4, with effect from the close of the annual meeting of
shareholders.
19
ANNUAL MEETING
Any questions?
31 October 2019
20
31 October 2019
ANNUAL MEETING
Disclaimer
This presentation:
• Is provided for general information purposes and does not constitute investment advice or an offer of or invitation to purchase Chorus
securities.
• Includes forward-looking statements. These statements are not guarantees or predictions of future performance. They involve known
and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors, many of which are beyond Chorus’ control, and which may cause actual resultsto
differ materially from those contained in this presentation.
• Includes statements relating to past performance which should not be regarded as reliable indicators of future performance.
• Is current at the date of this presentation, unless otherwise stated. Except as required by law or the NZX Main Board and ASX listing
rules, Chorus is not under any obligation to update this presentation, whether as a result of new information, future events or otherwise.
• Should be read in conjunction with Chorus’ audited consolidated financial statements for the year to 30 June 2019 and NZX and ASX
market releases.
• Includes non-GAAP financial measures such as "EBITDA”. These measures do not have a standardised meaning prescribed by GAAP and
therefore may not be comparable to similar financial information presented by other entities. They should not be used in substitution for,
or isolation of, Chorus' audited consolidated financial statements. We monitor EBITDA as a key performance indicator and we believe it
assists investors in assessing the performance of the core operations of our business.
• Has been prepared with due care and attention. However, Chorus and its directors and employees accept no liability for any errorsor
omissions.
• Contains information from third parties Chorus believes reliable. However, no representations or warranties (express or implied) are
made as to the accuracy or completeness of such information.
21
Data sourced from publicly available filings. Our datasets may not be complete. Automated analysis can produce errors. If you believe any data on this page is incorrect, please contact us at hello@nzxplorer.co.nz. For informational purposes only. Not investment advice.
Other issuers discussed similar conditions around this time
Matched by meaning across NZX announcement text, not keywords — based on our semantic index of announcement bodies.
- CEN — Contact Energy Limited: 2019 Annual Shareholder Meeting2019-11-12
“Contact Energy Limited. Level 2 Harbour City Tower, 29 Brandon St, Wellington 6011. PO Box 10742 Wellington 6143. P: +64 4 499 4001 F: +64 4 499 4003 contactenergy.co.nz 13 November 2019 CEO’s Address to Contact Energy 2019 Annual Meeting of Shareholders Introduction…”
- STU — Steel & Tube Holdings Limited: 2019 Annual Shareholder Meeting Presentation & Speeches2019-09-25
“1 STEEL AND TUBE ANNUAL MEETING 25 September 2019 CHAIR AND CEO SPEECHES 1. WELCOME Tēnā koutou, tēnā koutou, tēnā koutou katoa. Good afternoon and welcome. I’m Susan Paterson, the Chair of your company. Thank you for coming along to our annual meeting today. This is th…”
- VCT — Vector Limited: Notice of Annual Meeting 20192019-08-26
“2 ORDINARY RESOLUTIONS: Ordinary resolutions are required to be approved by a simple majority of more than 50% of votes validly cast at the Annual Meeting. SPECIAL RESOLUTION: Special resolutions are required to be approved by a special majority of 75% of votes validly cast at…”