SML – Waiver from NZX Listing Rule 5.1.1(b)
32639712_7
30 May 2024
NZX Regulation Limited (NZ RegCo)
Level 2, NZX Centre
11 Cable Street
Wellington
Email: issuer@nzregco.com
Synlait Milk Limited (SML) - Directors' certificate
We refer to the proposed waiver to be issued by NZX Regulation Limited to allow SML and its subsidiaries
to enter into and perform Relevant Contracts (as such term is defined in the waiver).
As the non-interested directors of SML, we hereby certify to NZX that:
(a) the granting of the waiver is in the best interest of each of SML and SML's shareholders as a
whole;
(b) the Relevant Contracts will not significantly change the nature of SML's business and will be in
the ordinary course of SML's business;
(c) the Relevant Contracts are in the best interest of each of SML and SML's shareholders as a
whole; and
(d) the entry into and performance of one or more Relevant Contracts is not, and will not be, a major
transaction requiring shareholder approval of SML's shareholders for the purposes of the
Companies Act 1993.
The core grounds for the certifications provided under paragraphs (a) and (b) above are:
(1) the entry into and performance of the Relevant Contracts are arrangements where SML is
undertaking business as usual activities involving the supply of dairy and non-dairy products
derived from, or manufactured using, dairy and non-dairy products and raw materials supplied to
it for payment under contract, and the procurement of products, raw materials or services
involved in such supply, and are not transactions that significantly change the nature of its
business;
(2) the entry into of the Relevant Contracts are intended to provide further revenue to SML's
business, improve SML's financial performance and maximise shareholder value in the long term;
(3) due solely to the recent material deterioration in SML's share price, contracts which are regularly
entered into by SML (and have been for many years as part of its ongoing operations) are now
being caught by Listing Rule 5.1.1. SML's shareholders have never previously been required to
approve these business as usual contracts, and the non-interested directors of SML do not
consider SML's shareholders would expect to have to approve those types of contracts, being
contracts for the sale of its manufactured goods (or for the supply to it of materials to allow the
manufacture and sale of those goods). There is also potential that certain counterparties would
express concern with details of the business as usual contracts being included in a notice of
meeting, such that certain Relevant Contracts may not be entered into if they were subject to
SML shareholder approval; and
(4) the financial and time costs of convening and holding multiple shareholder meetings during the
course of the coming year to approve the entry into and performance of business as usual
contracts far outweigh the benefits.
2
This certificat
e may be signed by the relevant non-interested directors of SML in one or more
counterparts (by PDF or otherwise), each of which when so signed will be deemed to be an original and
such counterparts together will constitute one and the same instrument.
DirectorDirector
Print name Print name
DirectorDirector
Print name Print name
DirectorDirector
Print name Print name
Director
Print name
Paul Douglas McGilvary
Thomas Harold George Adams
Hon Ruth Margaret RichardsonPaul David Washer
Sihang Yang
Yi Zhu
Tao Zhang
---
29 May 2024
NZ RegCo Decision
Synlait Milk Limited (NS) (SML)
Application for Waiver from NZX Listing Rule 5.1.1(b)
NZ RegCo
1
Background
1. The approval from NZX Regulation Limited (NZ RegCo) for the waiver set out in the decisions below
will not apply if the information provided by SML is not, or ceases to be, full and accurate in all
material respects.
2. Capitalised terms which have not been defined in this decision have the meaning given to them in the
NZX Listing Rules (Rules).
3. The information on which this decision is based is set out in Appendix One to this decision. This
decision will not apply if that information is not or ceases to be full and accurate in all material
respects.
4. The Rules to which these decisions relate are set out in Appendix Two to this decision.
Waiver from Rule 5.1.1(b)
Decision
5. Subject to the conditions set out in paragraph 6 below, and on the basis that the information provided
by Synlait Milk Limited (NS) (SML) is complete and accurate in all material respects, NZ RegCo grants
SML a waiver from Rule 5.1.1(b), to the extent required to allow SML to enter into the Relevant
Contracts during a period from 12-months from the date of the waiver and perform the Relevant
Contracts without needing to obtain shareholder approval.
6. The waivers contained in paragraph 5 are subject to conditions that:
a. SML’s Non-Interested Directors certify to NZX that the granting of the waiver is in the best interest
of each of:
i SML, and
ii SML’s shareholders as a whole,
b. SML’s Non-Interested Directors certify to NZX that the Relevant Contracts will:
i not significantly change the nature of SML's business, and
ii be in the ordinary course of SML's business,
c. SML’s Non-Interested Directors certify to NZX that the Relevant Contracts are in the best interest
of each of:
i SML, and
ii SML’s shareholders as a whole,
d. SML’s Non-Interested Directors include in the certificate a summary of the core grounds for the
certifications given under each limb of conditions (a), (b), and (c), described above,
e. SML’s Non-Interested Directors certify to NZX that
entry into and performance of one or more
Relevant Contracts
is not, and will not be, a major transaction requiring shareholder approval of
SML's shareholders for the purposes of the Companies Act 1993, and
f. the waiver and its conditions and implications are disclosed in SML's annual report for the financial
year ending 31 July 2024.
NZ RegCo
2
7. NZ RegCo will publish the certificate to market alongside publication of this waiver decision.
Reasons
8. In coming to the decision to provide the waivers set out in paragraph 5 above, NZ RegCo has
considered that:
a. SML has submitted, and NZ RegCo has no reason not to accept, that the granting of the waiver is
in the best interest of each of SML and its shareholders as a whole. The conditions of the waiver
require the Non-Interested Directors of SML to give certification to this effect, which will be
published to market.
b. The policy behind Rule 5.1.1(b) is to regulate those transactions which have a value that
represents a majority of the equity that investors hold in the Issuer and, as a result, are deemed to
be so significant to the Issuer, and therefore so likely to impact shareholders’ interests, that
shareholders should have an opportunity to consider the transaction and exercise their right to
vote before the transaction can take effect.
Major transactions significantly change the nature of
an Issuer’s business or represent a majority of the equity that investors hold in the Issuer, and are
therefore significant.
c. SML has submitted, and NZ RegCo has no reason not to accept, that the circumstances
underpinning this waiver do not offend the policy behind Rule 5.1.1(b), and the application of Rule
5.1.1(b) in respect of entry into and performance of the Relevant Contracts would otherwise
impose an unreasonable and disproportionate restriction on SML's ability to enter into long term
and multi-year arrangements where it would receive payment or pay for procurement undertaking
business as usual activities:
i the entry into and performance of the Relevant Contracts
are arrangements where SML is
undertaking business as usual activities involving the supply of dairy and non-dairy products
derived from, or manufactured using, dairy and non-dairy products and raw materials
supplied to it for payment under contract, and the procurement of products, raw materials or
services involved in such supply, rather than being transactions that significantly change the
nature of its business. The conditions of the waiver require SML’s Non-Interested Directors
of SML to give certification to this effect;
ii the entry into of the Relevant Contracts are in the best interests of each of SML and its
shareholders as a whole as they are intended to provide further revenue to SML's business,
improve SML's financial performance and maximise shareholder value in the long term.
The conditions of the waiver require SML’s Non-Interested Directors of SML to give
certification to this effect;
iii the waiver is restricted to a period of 12 months from the date of this waiver and applies
only to Relevant Contracts, being, in summary, contracts which are within SML’s usual
business activities, involving the supply
of dairy and non-dairy products derived from, or
manufactured using, dairy and non-dairy products and raw materials supplied to it for
payment under contract, and the procurement of products, raw materials or services
involved in such supply, in excess of 50% of SML’s AMC.
On expiry of the waiver, SML will
need to consider whether shareholder approval under Rule 5.1.1(b) is required before
entering into, or renewing, any other similar contracts
;
and
iv the major transaction provisions of the Companies Act 1993 provide that transactions the
value of which exceed 50% of the value of the company’s assets must be approved by a
special resolution of shareholders, or be contingent upon such approval. This requirement
cannot be waived. SML's shareholders retain the protections of the Companies Act 1993 for
transactions that are significant compared to the value of the company’s assets, and will
have the opportunity to vote on these transactions. In this instance, SML submits that the
entry into and performance of the potential Relevant Contracts will not trigger this
requirement for SML and SML shareholder approval is not required by the Companies Act
NZ RegCo
3
1993. The conditions of the waiver require the Non-Interested Directors of SML to give
certification to this effect.
d. The NZX Guidance Note Major and Related Party Transactions provides examples of the limited
situations in which NZ RegCo might grant a waiver from Rule 5.1.1, such as if an Issuer is entering
into a multi-year arrangement where it is receiving cash under a contract in excess of 50% of the
Issuer’s Average Market Capitalisation where the Issuer is undertaking business as usual
activities. SML’s entry into and performance of the Relevant Contracts are arrangements where it
is undertaking business as usual activities for cash consideration which is analogous to the
example provided in the NZX Guidance Note.
e. There is precedent for this decision.
Confidentiality
9. SML has requested that this decision be kept confidential until NZ RegCo finalises and releases this
decision.
10. In accordance with Rule 9.7.2, NZ RegCo grants SML's request.
NZ RegCo
4
Appendix One
Further Information
1. Synlait Milk Limited (
SML
) is a Listed Issuer with Equity Securities
Quoted on the NZX Main Board.
2.
The SML Group is a dairy and non-dairy manufacturer, with its primary business being the supply of
high value advanced nutritional formulas and powders, dairy ingredients and liquid dairy products to
leading health and nutrition companies internationally. As part of its business as usual activities, SML
undertakes the supply of dairy and non-dairy products derived from, or manufactured using, dairy and
non-dairy products and raw materials supplied to it for payment under contract and the procurement of
products, raw materials or services involved in such supply. Certain of those products do not relate
exclusively to those products and ingredients. A number of those contracts can be for multi-year terms.
3.
SML’s market capitalisation is currently around $100 million. Relative to its market capitalisation, SML is
a significant business, with $1.6 billion of revenue in FY23, total assets of approximately $1.7 billion and
net assets of approximately $700 million as at 31 January 2024.
4.
Accordingly, certain contracts entered into by SML when undertaking business as usual activities have
a Gross Value of more than 50% of the Average Market Capitalisation of SML. Under Rule 5.1.1(b) the
entering into of these transactions, or a related series of transactions, involving the acquisition or
disposal of assets (which includes cash) which involves a Gross Value above 50% of the AMC of the
Issuer requires shareholder approval by way of an ordinary resolution.
5.
For the purposes of this waiver,
Relevant Contracts
are contracts entered into and performed by SML
or any of subsidiaries (the
SML Group
and each a
SML Group Member
) as part of business as usual
transactions and which are principally:
(a) for the purchase and payment for dairy products or non-dairy nutritional products;
(b) for the purchase and payment for products, raw materials or services involved in the
manufacture and sale of dairy products and non-dairy nutritional products; or
(c) with a customer for the supply by a SML Group Member of dairy products or non-dairy nutritional
products derived from, or manufactured using, dairy products or non-dairy nutritional products or
raw materials supplied to a SML Group Member,
to the extent that such Relevant Contract:
(d) is entered into in the 12-month period after the date of the waiver;
(e) has a Gross Value of more than 50% of SML's Average Market Capitalisation; and
(f) is a transaction or series of related transactions falling within, or in connection with, (a), (b) or (c)
above.
6.
While
the Relevant Contracts are principally for the matters set out in paragraph 5(a), (b) and (c) above,
SML also expects that the agreements may also have non-material components of capital investment,
trial or registration services. Examples of these ancillary matters are the use of specific tools or storage,
emissions reduction activity, or product development. SML submits that these ancillary matters are
standard features for contracts of this nature and it would be commercially difficult to enter into the
Relevant Contracts without also agreeing the ancillary matters.
NZ RegCo
5
Appendix Two
Rule 5.1 Disposal or Acquisition of Assets
5.1.1 An Issuer must not enter into any transaction, or a related series of transactions, to acquire, sell, lease
(whether as lessor or lessee), exchange, or otherwise (except by way of charge) dispose of assets
where the transaction or related series of transactions:
(a) would significantly change, either directly or indirectly, the nature of the Issuer's business; or
(b) involves a Gross Value above 50% of the Average Market Capitalisation of the Issuer,
unless the transaction, or related series of transactions, is:
(c) approved by an Ordinary Resolution, or a special resolution if approval by way of special
resolution is required under section 129 of the Companies Act 1993, or
(d) conditional upon such approval required by paragraph (c) above.
Data sourced from publicly available filings. Our datasets may not be complete. Automated analysis can produce errors. If you believe any data on this page is incorrect, please contact us at hello@nzxplorer.co.nz. For informational purposes only. Not investment advice.
Other issuers discussed similar conditions around this time
Matched by meaning across NZX announcement text, not keywords — based on our semantic index of announcement bodies.
- TWL — TradeWindow Holdings Limited: TWL – Waiver from NZX Listing Rule 7.8.5(b)2024-05-26
“NZ RegCo 0 27 May 2024 NZ RegCo Decision Trade Window Holdings Limited (TWL) Application for waiver from NZX Listing Rule 7.8.5(b) NZ RegCo 1 Background 1. The information on which this decision is based is set out in Appendix…”