BFG Special shareholders meeting results & Chairs address
1
14 December 2023
Results of Burger Fuel Group Limited Special Shareholders Meeting
Burger Fuel Group Limited (BFG) advises that the scheme of arrangement relating to the return
of capital to shareholders (Scheme) has been approved by shareholders at BFG's special
shareholder meeting held today at the Rakiura Room, Parkside Hotel & Apartments, 100 Greys
Avenue, Auckland, 1010 and via Computershare’s online web platform (Scheme Meeting).
As required by NZX Listing Rule 6.1, all voting was conducted by a poll.
To proceed, the Scheme required:
• 75% or more of the votes in each interest class who were entitled to vote and who
actually voted to have been voted in favour of the Scheme Resolution; and
• more than 50% of the total number of BFG shares on issue to have been voted in favour
of the Scheme Resolution.
The resolution passed by shareholders (Scheme Resolution) was:
• THAT the scheme of arrangement relating to the return of capital to shareholders, as set
out in the Arrangement Document incorporated in the Explanatory Notes in the Notice
of Special Meeting, be approved.
At the Scheme Meeting, the voting results were as follows:
Voting threshold For Against Abstain
Total votes cast in sole interest class:
Total votes cast by holders of ordinary
shares in BFG
38,450,239
92.92%
2,929,542
7.08%
759
0.00%
Total votes: Total number of shares on
issue voted
38,450,239
76.39%
2,929,542
5.82%
759
0.00%
Authority for this announcement
Name of person authorised to make this
announcement
Mark Piet
CFO / Company Secretary
Contact person for this announcement Mark Piet
Contact phone number 021 453 333
Contact email address Mark.Piet@Burgerfuel.com
Date of release through MAP 14/12/2023
---
1
BURGER FUEL GROUP LIMITED
Special Shareholders Meeting of BURGER FUEL GROUP LIMITED.
To be held online and in person at Rakiura Room, Parkside Hotel & Apartments,
100 Greys Avenue, Auckland, 1010
Thursday 14 December 2023 at 11.30 am.
Chair’s Address
Introduction
Good morning, Ladies and Gentlemen. My name is Peter Brook and I’m the
Chair of the Burger Fuel Group.
On behalf of the board, I would like to welcome you all to this Special
Shareholders Meeting of BurgerFuel to discuss and vote on the proposed Return
of Capital.
We have decided to run a hybrid meeting for this special meeting via the
Computershare Online Meetings platform. This allows Shareholders, Proxies and
Guests who were not able to travel and attend the meeting in person the ability
to attend the meeting virtually. All online attendees can watch a live webcast
of the meeting. In addition, shareholders and proxies have the ability to ask
questions and submit votes, so I also welcome the shareholders that chose to
attend online.
For those of you attending the meeting virtually, if you have a question to submit
during the live meeting, please select the Q&A tab on the right half of your
screen anytime. Type your question into the field and press send. Your question
will be immediately submitted. Should you require any assistance, you can type
your query and one of the Computershare team will assist with the chat function
and reply to your query. Alternatively, you can call Computershare on
0800-650-034.
Please note that while you can submit questions from now on, these will not be
addressed until the relevant time in the meeting. Please also note that your
questions may be moderated or if we receive multiple questions on one topic,
amalgamated together.
2
Before I explain the voting procedures for the meeting, I would like to inform
shareholders that yesterday afternoon we received a letter from lawyers acting
for Christopher Mason in his capacity as trustee of the Mason Family Trust which is
an approximately 4.8% shareholder. His lawyers have asked us to note Mr Mason's
opposition to the capital return arrangement at today's meeting. His lawyers
have also informed us that they have instructions from their client to file a notice
of opposition to the application for final orders in the court proceedings. If a
notice of opposition is filed by Mr Mason or any other shareholders, the Company
will continue to seek final orders to have the capital return implemented as set
out in the notice of meeting because the Board continues to believe the capital
return is in the best interests of the Company and its shareholders and fair to all
shareholders.
Voting today will be conducted by way of a poll. In order to provide all online
attendees with enough time to vote, we will now open the online voting for the
special resolution.
If you are eligible to vote at this meeting and are attending online, you will be
able to cast your vote online under the Vote tab. The resolution will allow votes to
be submitted. To vote, simply select your voting direction from the options shown
on screen. Your vote has been cast when the tick appears. To change your vote,
simply select ‘Change Your Vote’. You have the ability to change your vote, up
until the time I declare voting closed. If you need to leave the meeting early,
please ensure your vote is cast before you exit and leave the meeting.
For those of you here in person, voting on voting papers will be done a little later
in the meeting.
The notice convening the meeting was circulated to shareholders on the 15th of
November 2023.
As a quorum is present, I have pleasure in formally declaring the meeting open.
3
Introduction of Board
I would now like to take this opportunity to introduce your Directors and Chief
Financial Officer who are Present at this meeting.
Josef Roberts – Director & CEO
Tyrone Foley – Director
Alan Gourdie, an independent Director like myself.
Mark Piet - CFO/Company Secretary
I would also like to welcome other BurgerFuel executives together with our
Auditors and Share Registrar.
The agenda for today’s meeting will be as follows.
Firstly, I will deliver an address. We will then conclude the address with any Q&A.
From there we will move to the formal part of the meeting. In terms of formal
business, we have one special resolution to put to the meeting. We will invite any
questions specific to this resolution.
Please note, this meeting is to specifically discuss the special resolution regarding
the return of capital as detailed in the notice of meeting, this is not an open forum
to discuss general business.
For those present in the meeting room today we have a couple of housekeeping
matters.
Please note the toilets are across the hall at the back of the room, and the fire
exit stairs are on the right just before the elevators where you came in. In the
event of a fire please make your way to the fire exit and assemble in front of the
building.
4
Chairman Address - Capital Return
On 27 October 2023, Burger Fuel Group Limited announced its intention to return
approximately NZ$4.077 million of capital to shareholders on a pro rata basis by a
way of a Court approved scheme of arrangement.
The Company currently has excess cash, that is, over and above the cash
needed for its working capital requirements for the foreseeable future.
The origins of the Company's excess cash and unrestricted capital assets is a
result of the issue of shares to, and subsequent buy-back of shares at a lower cost
from, Franchise Brands LLC, a company affiliated to the Subway® Corporation of
USA, in connection with expansion plans which were not fully implemented. As
such, most of the cash was surplus capital that is not being used for a particular
investment opportunity.
The Company has been through an extensive exercise to determine the best use
of its excess cash. The directors of the Company do not believe that any suitable
investment opportunities exist at present or are likely in the short to medium term
for the full amount of the cash currently held within the Company. It is not
efficient for the Company to retain its current level of unrestricted capital and in
these circumstances it is most appropriate to return surplus capital to
shareholders.
In determining the preferred form of capital return, the Company sought advice
from its external legal advisers, its auditors, and tax advisers. After careful
consideration by the Board, it was decided that the Scheme was the preferred
option available as firstly the accumulated cash originated from capital obtained
from the Franchise Brands transaction and secondly it was the most tax efficient
means of returning excess cash to shareholders.
30% of your shares will be cancelled (together with all rights attaching to those
shares) and in return you will receive NZ$0.27 for each cancelled share.
Shareholders registered on the Company’s share register as the holder of shares
in the Company at 5:00pm on the proposed Record Date which is expected to
be Tuesday 13 February 2024, will have shares cancelled and be paid the NZ$0.27
for each share cancelled.
5
If multiplying the number of shares you own by 30% does not result in a whole
number, then the resulting number will be rounded up or down to the nearest
whole number of shares (with 0.5 rounded up).
On the Record Date there are expected to be 50,336,863 shares on issue. Based
on this number, cancellation of 30% of the total shares on issue will result in
approximately 15,101,059 ordinary shares being cancelled (subject to rounding).
This will leave the total number of ordinary shares on issue at approximately
35,235,804 (subject to rounding).
The return of capital will not alter your proportionate shareholding in the
Company, or your proportionate voting and distribution rights, and will be by way
of a Court and shareholder-approved process. It is important to note that
following the cancellation of shares, you will have the same proportionate
shareholding and voting interest as before that cancellation. To confirm,
shareholders will not be diluted by the return of capital.
Payment to shareholders will be made by direct credit in the case of those
shareholders who have provided bank account details to Computershare.
Direct credits will be made within ten business days after the Record Date.
Shareholders will be issued with a new shareholding statement showing the new
number of shares held following the cancellation of shares. Both the payment to
shareholders and the provision of a new shareholding statement will be
undertaken by Computershare.
It is important to ensure Computershare have your correct bank account details
to receive the payment so please contact Computershare if you haven’t
already.
It is expected that the payment to shareholders will occur by Tuesday 27 February
2024.
This Scheme meets the requirements under the Income Tax Act 2007 (NZ) to be
treated as a return of capital and not a dividend, this means the payment will
generally not be taxable for New Zealand shareholders subject to certain
exceptions which were set out in the notice of meeting. We encourage you to
seek professional tax advice on the effect of the capital return based on your
personal circumstances if you aren’t sure.
6
Voting
This brings us to the formal part of the meeting and the special resolutions set out
in the notice of meeting that has been previously circulated.
The items of business comprise one special resolution required to be passed by at
least 75% of votes of shareholders who are entitled to vote and exercise their right
to vote on the resolution and a simple majority of the votes of those shareholders
entitled to vote.
When the board was deciding whether the scheme of arrangement relating to
the return of capital to shareholders should proceed, although Josef Roberts was
entitled to vote he opted not to be counted in the quorum or vote at the board
level due to being a majority shareholder. He is entitled to vote today as a
shareholder and has done so.
The Board recommends that shareholders vote in favour of the Scheme.
The special resolution is;
THAT the scheme of arrangement relating to the return of capital to shareholders,
as set out in the Arrangement Document incorporated in the Explanatory Notes in
the Notice of Special Meeting, be approved.
If anyone has any questions on this special resolution, please ask online now or for
those shareholders present here at the meeting, by raising your hand, we will
repeat the question back for the benefit of those online.
Once again, I remind you that this meeting is to specifically discuss the special
resolution regarding the return of capital, this is not an open forum to discuss
general business.
Before we open the floor for questions, I will address and clarify some frequently
asked questions.
7
1. Why a Return of Capital?
The origins of the Company's excess cash and unrestricted capital assets is
a result of the issue of shares to, and subsequent buy-back of shares at a
lower cost from, Franchise Brands LLCin connection with expansion plans
which were not fully implemented. As such, most of the cash was surplus
capital that is not being used for a particular investment opportunity.
A capital return is not uncommon and other companies have done this,
including Sky Television, Tilt Renewables, Fonterra and Tower.
2. Why not a dividend?
After careful consideration by the Board, it was decided that the Scheme
was the preferred option available as firstly the accumulated cash
originated from capital obtained from the Franchise Brands transaction
and secondly it was the most tax efficient means of returning excess cash
to shareholders.
Furthermore, the company doesn’t have sufficient retained earnings on its
balance sheet to justify paying a dividend. As at 30 September 2023 BFG
has retained earnings of approximately $790K so any dividend payments
would be based off future potential earnings, and in this uncertain
economic environment, it would be unwise.
3. Who benefits from the return of capital?
All shareholders benefit from the return of capital. All shareholders are
treated equally, and shares are cancelled on a pro-rata basis. Everyone’s
percentage shareholding remains the same as before the return of capital.
To confirm, shareholders will not be diluted by the return of capital.
4. How was the $0.27 payment derived?
$0.27 cents was the market value when the announcement of the capital
return was made, which is in line with the volume-weighted average share
price over the last 30,60,90 days & 12 months before 16 October 2023.
5. What was the $0.08 mentioned in the announcement.
This was to simply demonstrate the amount that each shareholder would
receive (from the return of capital) per share based on their current
shareholding. This was calculated by dividing the $4.077M distribution over
the total existing shares of 50,336,863.
8
Obviously, 30 percent of the shares will be cancelled, thus another way to
look at this, is that each shareholder is receiving $0.27 per cancelled share.
Q&A - We will now take any questions.
Thank you I will now conclude the resolution questions.
Voting
Can I please ask you to now mark your voting papers. You will need to mark the
voting form that was sent with the Notice of Meeting or provided to you at the
beginning of this meeting.
Shareholders who are entitled to vote and proxies who have discretion as to how
they vote will have received a Proxy/Voting Form prior to the meeting or been
issued with a form when they registered upon arrival at the meeting here today.
If you submitted a proxy prior to the meeting, you do not need to complete
another Proxy/Voting form.
If you do not have a form, please go to the Computershare desk at the back of
the room where their representatives will be able to assist you.
For those in the room after voting, you should place your Proxy/Voting Form in
one of the ballot boxes which Computershare will bring around the room at the
conclusion of the formal part of the meeting. Please ensure you sign the form
before placing your form in the ballot box.
For those online a reminder that your vote has been cast when the tick appears.
In a minute I will close the voting system. Please ensure you have cast your vote
on the resolution. Computershare will now collect votes from within the room
and following this voting will be closed.
For those of you online, voting can occur as indicated at the introduction to this
meeting.
9
Announcement of Result
The results of today’s meeting will be published via the NZX market
announcement platform later today.
Closure
Thank you everyone - as there is no further official business, I now declare the
meeting closed.
I wish you all the best for the remainder of the year and have a safe and
wonderful Christmas.
Once again thank you for your attendance today.
MEETING DECLARED CLOSED AT 12.02pm.
Data sourced from publicly available filings. Our datasets may not be complete. Automated analysis can produce errors. If you believe any data on this page is incorrect, please contact us at hello@nzxplorer.co.nz. For informational purposes only. Not investment advice.
Other issuers discussed similar conditions around this time
Matched by meaning across NZX announcement text, not keywords — based on our semantic index of announcement bodies.
- FBU — Fletcher Building: Results of 2023 Annual Shareholders Meeting2023-10-27
“Meeting Results Announcement Fletcher Building Limited, Private Bag 92114, Auckland 1142, 810 Great South Road, Penrose, Auckland 1061, New Zealand 27 October 2023 Results of Fletcher Building Limited 2023 Annual Shareholders’ Meeting At Fletcher Building Limited’s 20…”
- MEE — Me Today Limited: Special Meeting Results2024-03-08
“Level 1, 25 Broadway, Newmarket, Auckland 1141 8 th March 2023 Results of Me Today special meeting of shareholders At Me Today Limited’s special meeting of shareholders held a t Events on Khyber, Level 2, 155 Khyber Pass Road, Grafton, Auckland 1023 at 11am on 8 M…”
- BAI — Being AI: Results of annual meeting2023-09-19
“Ascension Capital Limited PO Box 42 258 Orakei Auckland 1745 19 September 2023 Results of Ascension Capital Limited Annual Shareholder Meeting At Ascension Capital Limited’s shareholder meeting, held at Auckland today, shareholders were asked to vote on three resoluti…”