Get NZX governance insights in your inbox
Weekly digest of board changes, insider trades, and market signals. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Get NZX governance insights in your inbox
Weekly digest of board changes, insider trades, and market signals. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
A structured side-by-side comparison of the FY2025 climate-related disclosures prepared by Contact Energy (CEN), Genesis Energy (GNE), Mercury NZ (MCY) and Meridian Energy (MEL). Covers consolidation approach, organisational boundary, GHG accounting standard cited, base year, emission-factor source, Scope 3 category coverage, intensity denominator, scenario analysis, transition plan disclosure, assurance provider and scope, and restatements. Every data point is cited to a page of the original source document.
A reader comparing “total emissions” across NZ’s four listed gentailers is comparing four different things — not because the companies disagree, but because NZ CS permits it.
Contact, Genesis, Mercury and Meridian all report under the Aotearoa New Zealand Climate Standards (NZ CS 1–3). But the GHG accounting standards each company states its inventory against differ. So does the base year. So does the set of Scope 3 categories estimated. So does the level and scope of independent assurance.
The result is a sector-level methodology-basis gap that makes a straight “total emissions” comparison meaningless unless the reader corrects for it. This page lists every material methodology choice each company made, and cites the page of the source document where each choice appears. The companion GHG Assurance Audit 2026 narrows the lens to the assurance dimension specifically.
All four cite the GHG Protocol; Meridian also states its inventory against ISO 14064-1:2018.
“Scope 3 emissions” means a different boundary depending on which company you read.
Three of four hold reasonable assurance on Scope 1 & 2; all four engagements cite NZ SAE 1. A-G = carried out on the Auditor-General’s behalf (FMCA s461ZH(3)).
Each company publishes a “total emissions” figure in its FY2025 climate statement. What goes into that total differs company by company. The share of Meridian’s reported total that comes from Scope 3 is 94%. The share of Genesis’s total from Scope 3 is 29%. A reader comparing totals across the four is implicitly weighting Scope 3 differently for each.
| Issuer | Reported total | Scope 1 + 2 | Scope 3 | S3 share | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GNE | 3.59M Scope 1 + Scope 2 (location-based) + Scope 3 | 2.54M | 1.05M | 29% | p.50 |
| CEN | 1.11M Scope 1 + Scope 2 (location-based) + Scope 3 | 742k | 370k | 33% | p.30 |
| MCY | 425k Scope 1 + Scope 2 (location-based) + Scope 3 | 219k | 205k | 48% | p.18 |
| MEL | 53k Scope 1 + Scope 2 (location-based) + Scope 3 (Table 7 “Total Group value chain emissions”) | 3.1k | 50k | 94% | p.34 |
Absolute tonnes CO2-e, extracted directly from each issuer’s FY2025 climate statement. All four report Scope 1 and Scope 2 separately; location-based Scope 2 is used above. Meridian’s own target tracking uses market-based Scope 2 (Scope 1 + 2 = 715 tCO2-e).
Composition of each issuer’s reported “total emissions”
How to read this. The rank order of the four is preserved under any of these views — Genesis is largest, Meridian smallest. What the figures show is that “total emissions” is not a single comparable metric across the sector. For a like-for-like risk comparison, use Scope 1 + Scope 2 only (as reported or as location-based) and treat Scope 3 category-by-category, not in aggregate.
Each bar shows how many of the 15 GHG Protocol Scope 3 categories the issuer reports quantitatively in its FY2025 climate statement. The gap between the shortest and longest bar is the comparability problem in one picture.
“Total emissions” published by GNE or CEN (10 categories each) and by MCY (5 categories) are not measuring the same thing. Neither approach is wrong under NZ CS as written. That is the underlying policy choice.
Each row is a methodological choice a climate statement preparer must make. Every data point cites the page of the source PDF where the value is stated; direct quotes are shown in italics.
| Field | CEN Contact Energy Limited 1 July 2024 – 30 June 2025 · 42 pages | MEL Meridian Energy Limited 1 July 2024 – 30 June 2025 (Year 7 of climate reporting) · 54 pages | GNE Genesis Energy Limited 1 July 2024 – 30 June 2025 · 79 pages | MCY Mercury NZ Limited 1 July 2024 – 30 June 2025 · 30 pages |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Consolidation approach | Operational controlp.28 Re-verified 2026-10-17 against the Climate Statement 2025. | Operational consolidation approachp.36 “Meridian’s emissions are calculated using the operational consolidation approach.” | Operational controlp.61 “Genesis has applied the operational control consolidation approach, which ensures we focus on those emission sources that we have control over and therefore the ability to manage.” | Operational controlp.26 “The approach used to consolidate GHG emissions (operational control) on page 7 of the GHG Emissions Inventory report.” |
Organisational boundary | Contact Energy Limited, Western Energy Services Limited and five other named subsidiaries; associates and joint arrangements excluded (no operational control)p.28 | Operations owned or controlled by Meridian, its subsidiaries, associate companies and joint ventures (set with reference to the GHG Protocol and ISO 14064-1)p.33 Operational control consolidation. Excludes emissions linked to financial derivatives, seasonal flexibility agreements and the Huntly Strategic Reserve (p.33), and historical Meridian Australia emissions (p.34). | Genesis and all its subsidiaries; all joint ventures, joint operations and associates excluded from Scope 1 and 2 (no operational control)p.61 The climate-statement reporting entity (p.4) is wider: subsidiaries, controlled entities and interests in associates and joint arrangements. Genesis’ 46% share of Kupe JV Scope 1 and 2 is carried in Scope 3 (Cat 3 for gas/LPG, Cat 15 for oil) (p.62). | Mercury NZ Limited and subsidiaries (the Group) — 19 power stations (hydro, geothermal, wind), retail electricity, gas, broadband and mobilep.4 Operational control. GHG Inventory Report p.7 includes 100% of Mercury NZ, Mercury Geothermal, TPC Holdings (25% associate), Rotokawa JV (64.8%), Ngā Awa Pūrua JV (65%) and NOW NZ. EnergySource LLC, EnergySource Minerals LLC and Forest Partners are treated as Cat 15 and assessed as immaterial. |
GHG standard cited | GHG Protocol Corporate Accounting and Reporting Standard (2004) + Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Standardp.28 Re-verified 2026-10-17. The earlier extraction (GRI / <IR>) was taken from the Integrated Report, not the Climate Statement. | ISO 14064-1:2018 + GHG Protocol Corporate Standard (Revised Edition) + Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Standard (2011)p.33 “Meridian’s GHG Inventory is stated in accordance with the requirements of: ISO 14064-1:2018 … the Greenhouse Gas Protocol: A Corporate Accounting and Reporting Standard (Revised Edition). the Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Accounting and Reporting Standard (2011).” | GHG Protocol Corporate Standardp.61 “The GHG inventory has been prepared in accordance with the requirements of the GHG Protocol which is an internationally recognised framework for carbon reporting.” | GHG Protocol Corporate Standard (revised edition) + Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Standardp.18 “We produce an annual Greenhouse Gas Emissions Inventory Report in accordance with The Greenhouse Gas Protocol: A Corporate Accounting and Reporting Standard (revised edition) and the Corporate Value Chain (Scope 3) Accounting and Reporting Standard.” |
Base year (and reason) | FY2018p.29 First year that includes all three scopes (Scope 2 and 3 reported since 2018). | FY2021p.35 Base year for SBTi-verified “Half by 30” absolute-reduction targets. | FY2020 (1 July 2019 – 30 June 2020)p.63 Consistent with the base year used for its SBTs. FY20 Scope 1+2 = 2,690,253 tCO2e; Scope 3 = 1,804,749 tCO2e. | FY2022 (year ended 30 June 2022)p.12 Base year for SBTi-aligned reduction targets; FY25 emissions intensity 0.023 kg CO2e/kWh (8.9% below base). |
Emission-factor source | Geothermal unique emission factors and natural-gas factors under the Climate Change regulations; MfE Measuring Emissions 2025 detailed guide; ThinkStep ANZ 2024 spend-based factors (Scope 3)p.29 | Latest MfE or UK DESNZ factors; Thinkstep (spend-based), BRANZ CO2NSTRCT (construction), BraveTrace (residual electricity factors). GWP: IPCC AR5, 100-yearp.33 “Emissions factors were sourced from the latest publication of New Zealand’s Ministry for the Environment (MfE) or the UK’s Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, with additional data from Thinkstep (spend-based emissions factors) , BRANZ CO2NSTRCT (construction emissions factors), and BraveTrace (residual emissions factors for electricity not covered by renewable energy certificates).” | MfE 2025 Emissions Factors Workbook and Flat File for all scopes except Scope 3 Cat 1 & 2 (Market Economics 2023 Consumption Emissions Modelling Report for Auckland Council) and Cat 3 fuel & energy (Agrilink 2023 lifecycle factors). GWP: AR5 (MfE); AR4 (Agrilink, Market Economics)p.63 “We have used emission factors published by the Ministry for the Environment (MfE) for all scopes and categories except for:” | Geothermal unique emission factors from analysis of physical steam samples; MfE Measuring Emissions 2025 Emissions Factor Workbook; Thinkstep-anz 2024 v1.1. Cat 1/2 spend-based factors from the 2022 Thinkstep-ANZ dataset, CPI-adjusted. GWP: IPCC AR5p.15 Page is in the FY25 GHG Emissions Inventory Report (pp.14–16), which the Climate Statement (p.18) cross-refers for factors and GWPs. Geothermal UEFs are externally assured where steam properties deviate more than 5% from the prior year (assurance report, Climate Statement p.26). |
Intensity denominator | t CO2e per MWh of generation (FY25 total generation intensity 0.095)p.34 | t CO2e per GWh of generation (fuel-use emissions only; FY25: 0, renewable-only generation)p.34 | t CO2e (Scope 1 thermal-generation combustion) per GWh of total generation (FY25: 409); also per thermal GWh (703) and kg CO2e per $m retail revenue (0.55)p.51 | kg CO2e per kWh of generationp.18 FY25 intensity: 0.023 kg CO2e/kWh. Does not adjust for part-ownership of geothermal assets or NZ ETS credits. |
Scope 3 coverage | 10 of 15 GHG Protocol categoriesp.30 Disclosed: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 11, 13, 15 Categories 9, 10, 12 and 14 are excluded as not applicable (p.29); Category 8 is not mentioned. Category 11 (use of sold products) is the largest at 250,612 tCO2e. | 9 of 15 GHG Protocol categoriesp.34, 47–50 Disclosed: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 13, 15 Appendix B maps operational Scope 3 to Categories 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 13 (farms as downstream leased assets), one-time construction to Category 2, investments (NZ Windfarms) to Category 15, and electricity purchased and on-sold to Category 3 (market-based; 0 tCO2e in FY25; outside the Table 7 total). Categories 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 14 are not mentioned. | 10 of 15 GHG Protocol categoriesp.50, 62 Disclosed: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 11, 15 Inclusions in Table 1 and exclusions in Table 2 (p.62). Categories 8, 10, 12, 13 and 14 are excluded with justification; 8 and 13 emissions are said to sit in Scope 1/2, Cat 3 or Cat 11. FY25 is the first year Categories 4 and 9 are disclosed; comparatives were not restated (p.50). | 5 of 15 GHG Protocol categoriesp.3, 13 Disclosed: 1, 2, 3, 6, 11 Pages are in the GHG Emissions Inventory Report. Table 1 (p.3) quantifies Cat 1 (14,155), Cat 2 (66,192, ~32% of Scope 3), Cat 3 (T&D losses on imported electricity only, 186), Cat 6 (1,049) and Cat 11 (gas sales, 123,861). Table 9 (p.13) excludes Cats 4, 5, 7, 8, 12, 13 and 15 as below the materiality threshold and Cats 9, 10 and 14 as not applicable. The Climate Statement (pp.3, 12) says investments were added, but no Cat 15 figure is reported and the Inventory Report treats Cat 15 as immaterial. |
Scenario analysis | 3 scenarios · qualitativep.15–16 Co-ordinated Decarbonisation (1.3°C) · Disorderly Decarbonisation (2.6°C) · Hot House (4.1°C) Horizons: Short (to 2030), Medium (2030–2050), Long (2050–2080) | 3 scenarios · quantitativep.8, 14–22 Net Zero Revolution (1.5°C) · Adaptive Evolution (2.7°C) · Hot House (3°C+) Horizons: Short (to 2030), Medium (2030–2050), Long (2050–2100) | 4 scenarios · quantitativep.17, 19–22 Coordinated transformation (1.5°C) · Green tape (2.2°C) · Delayed transformation (2.6°C) · Hot house (3.3°C) Horizons: Short 2030, Medium 2040, Long 2050 | 4 scenarios · quantitativep.7, 13 Teal (1.5°C) · Purple (2.5°C) · Amber (3°C) · Maroon (3°C+) Horizons: Current <1yr, Short 1–3yr, Medium 3–10yr, Long 10–30yr |
Transition plan | Net zero Scope 1 and 2 by 2035 pathway (renewable build, closure of baseload thermal, carbon capture and reinjection)p.13, 27 Re-verified 2026-10-17; costing of the plan not re-checked. | Half by 30: absolute 50% Scope 1 & 2 (market-based) reduction by FY30 from FY21 (SBTi-approved, 1.5°C). The FY25 revision replaces the 50% absolute Scope 3 target with a 51.6% per-MW intensity target, reported from FY26 and submitted to SBTi (not yet verified). Net Zero: 90% Scope 1 & 2 by FY40 and 90% Scope 3 by FY50 (SBTi-verified FY25). Meridian states it is not on track for Half by 30 (p.36).p.31–32, 35–36 | Gen35 strategy — ~8,300 GWh renewable generation and 1,400 MW of flexible assets at Huntly by FY35; net zero 2040 target validated by SBTi in FY25. No total cost of the plan stated; capital deployment described qualitatively (p.44).p.35–44 | Strategy across five pillars — Kaitiakitanga, Kiritaki, Ngā Tāngata, Kōtuitanga, Arumoni. FY25 growth CAPEX $347m (100% renewable). SBTi target validation pending.p.4–5, 12 Costed project examples disclosed ($90m Karāpiro refurb, $4.5m NCG reinjection); full transition-plan cost quantification not published. |
Restatements | None disclosed | Yesp.34 FY25 acquisition of a 138-hectare Waikato dairy farm (2,376 tCO2e) triggered a Scope 3 base-year revision. Material acquisition changed the Scope 3 boundary sufficiently to require base-year adjustment. | None disclosed | Yesp.12, 18 FY22–FY24 Scope 3 restated to include Category 1 (purchased goods & services) and Category 2 (capital goods): FY24 Scope 3 rose by 38,262 tCO2e (~28%), from 136,335 to 174,597. Capital goods is 66,192 tCO2e in FY25 (restated FY24: 28,732). FY22–FY24 location-based Scope 2 was also restated (e.g. FY24 521 → 2,112 tCO2e) after improved electricity data. Completed full Scope 3 materiality assessment in FY25 under NZ CS; broader boundary adopted. The electricity restatement reflects improved consumption data (GHG Inventory Report p.4). |
Assurance provider | Ernst & Young Limited (EY), engaged directly by Contactp.38–41 NZ SAE 1 and ISAE (NZ) 3410 | Deloitte Limited on behalf of the Auditor-Generalp.52–54 NZ SAE 1 and ISAE (NZ) 3410 | Deloitte Limited on behalf of the Auditor-Generalp.71–74 NZ SAE 1 (mandatory GHG disclosures) and ISAE (NZ) 3410 | Ernst & Young Limited on behalf of the Auditor-Generalp.26–29 NZ SAE 1, ISAE (NZ) 3000 (Revised) and ISAE (NZ) 3410 |
Assurance level & scope | Reasonable (Scope 1, Scope 2 location-based, and Scope 3 Category 11 use of sold products); Limited (rest of Scope 3) Scope: Gross Scope 1, Scope 2 (location-based) and Scope 3 emissions (Climate Statement p.30), related additional GHG disclosures (pp.28–29) and methods, assumptions and estimation uncertainty (pp.31–32). The rest of the Climate Statement (pp.1–27, 33–37) is outside the engagement. Qualifications: Unmodified reasonable-assurance opinion and unmodified limited-assurance conclusion. Two key matters: (i) spend-based Scope 3 purchased goods & services and capital goods (~8% of total emissions, ~25% of Scope 3; emission-factor provider changed in FY25); (ii) Scope 1 geothermal emissions (~19% of total emissions). Other matter: FY18 base-year comparatives not assured. | Reasonable (Scope 1 & 2); Limited (Scope 3) Scope: Gross Scope 1, Scope 2 (location-based) and Scope 3 emissions (p.34) and the related NZ CS 1 para 24 and NZ CS 3 paras 52–54 disclosures (p.33 and Appendix B). Deloitte separately assured the GHG Emissions Inventory Report under ISAE (NZ) 3410 (separate limited assurance report). Qualifications: Unmodified reasonable-assurance opinion (Scope 1 & 2) and unmodified limited-assurance conclusion (Scope 3). No key matters reported. Other matter: FY21, FY23 and FY24 comparatives were not assured under NZ SAE 1. | Reasonable (Scope 1 & 2); Limited (Scope 3) Scope: Mandatory GHG disclosures in the Group Climate Statement (Scope 1, Scope 2 location-based, Scope 3) plus, as additional disclosures, the GHG Inventory Report in Appendix II — reasonable for Scope 1 & 2 and limited for Scope 3 in both. Qualifications: Unmodified reasonable-assurance opinion (Scope 1 & 2) and unmodified limited-assurance conclusion (Scope 3). No key matters reported. Other matter: FY20–FY24 comparatives were not assured under NZ SAE 1 (FY24 was assured by Deloitte under ISAE (NZ) 3410; FY20–FY23 by another provider). | Limited (Scope 1, 2 and 3) Scope: Scope 1, Scope 2 (location-based) and Scope 3 gross emissions; GHG Protocol compliance statement; consolidation approach; emission factors & GWP sources; exclusions; methods and uncertainty; base-year restatements — plus, by agreement, the other NZ CS disclosures on pp.1–24 of the Climate Statement that are not subject to mandatory assurance. Qualifications: Unmodified limited-assurance conclusion. Two key matters: (i) spend-based Scope 3 purchased goods & services and capital goods (~19% of total emissions, ~39% of Scope 3); (ii) Scope 1 geothermal emissions (~50% of total emissions), calculated with internally derived unique emission factors. Other matter: restated FY22–FY24 Scope 3 Categories 1 and 2 were not assured. |
The GHG Protocol defines 15 Scope 3 categories. “Disclosed” means a quantitative figure is stated. “Not estimated” means the company explicitly stated the category is not estimated for the reporting year. “Not disclosed” means no quantitative figure could be identified in the source document.
| GHG Protocol category | CEN | MEL | GNE | MCY |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Purchased goods & services | Disclosed | Disclosed | Disclosed | Disclosed |
| 2. Capital goods | Disclosed | Disclosed | Disclosed | Disclosed |
| 3. Fuel- & energy-related | Disclosed | Disclosed | Disclosed | Disclosed |
| 4. Upstream transport | Disclosed | Disclosed | Disclosed | — |
| 5. Waste | Disclosed | Disclosed | Disclosed | — |
| 6. Business travel | Disclosed | Disclosed | Disclosed | Disclosed |
| 7. Employee commuting | Disclosed | Disclosed | Disclosed | — |
| 8. Upstream leased assets | — | — | — | — |
| 9. Downstream transport | — | — | Disclosed | — |
| 10. Processing of sold products | — | — | — | — |
| 11. Use of sold products | Disclosed | — | Disclosed | Disclosed |
| 12. End-of-life | — | — | — | — |
| 13. Downstream leased assets | Disclosed | Disclosed | — | — |
| 14. Franchises | — | — | — | — |
| 15. Investments | Disclosed | Disclosed | Disclosed | — |
All four issuers apply the operational-control consolidation approach to their organisational boundary — but the standards they state their inventories against differ (Meridian adds ISO 14064-1:2018), and that matters because each framework defines category boundaries, reporting thresholds and disclosure expectations slightly differently.
The most material comparability gap sits in Scope 3. Genesis and Contact each report 10 of 15 categories, Meridian 9 and Mercury 5. A reader comparing “total emissions” across the four companies is therefore comparing four different things — not because the companies are dishonest, but because the standard permits meaningful preparer discretion on scope boundaries.
Base-year choice compounds this. Genesis uses FY2020, Meridian FY2021, Mercury FY2022 and Contact FY2018. Target progress reported against different base years is not directly comparable, even when both targets are expressed in the same percentage-reduction form. Mercury’s FY25 restatement of three prior years of Scope 3 — adding purchased goods and services and capital goods, which lifted restated FY24 Scope 3 by 38,262 tCO2e (~28%) — is a live illustration of how Scope 3 boundaries move year to year even at one company.
Assurance scope is the third axis. Three of four issuers (Contact, Genesis and Meridian) hold reasonable assurance on Scope 1 and 2; Mercury holds limited assurance across all three scopes. Scope 3 is at limited assurance for all four, except Contact’s Category 11 (use of sold products), which is inside its reasonable-assurance opinion. All four engagements were conducted under NZ SAE 1, yet the level and scope of assurance remain a comparability dimension in their own right.
Each data point in this page is extracted directly from the company’s FY2025 climate-related disclosures or integrated report. Page numbers refer to PDF page numbers of the source document. Direct quotes are preserved verbatim in italics; where a figure is stated but the exact page could not be isolated, the cell is left blank rather than populated with a guess.
Extraction date: 2026-04-20. Assurance fields, FY25 emissions figures and Contact’s methodology fields were re-verified against the primary documents on 2026-10-17; Genesis’, Mercury’s and Meridian’s methodology fields on 2026-10-18.
NZ CS as currently written permits the methodology discretion catalogued on this page. Three amendments would materially close the comparability gap without imposing new calculation burden:
Data sourced from publicly available records. Our datasets may not be complete. Automated analysis can produce errors. If you believe any data on this page is incorrect, please contact us at hello@nzxplorer.co.nz. For informational purposes only. Not investment advice.