NZ Electricity-Sector GHG Assurance Audit 2026
Four gentailers, four assurance reports. Three hold reasonable assurance over Scope 1 and 2; Mercury holds limited assurance across all three scopes. Scope 3 is at limited assurance for all four, except Contact’s Category 11 (use of sold products), which is at reasonable. That level gap is the first-order comparability dimension under NZ SAE 1.
Assurance posture — at a glance
Each cell shows the level of independent assurance obtained over the issuer’s FY2025 disclosure for that scope, as stated in the assurance report. Green is reasonable; amber is limited; the split cell is part reasonable, part limited.
Reasonable assurance is audit-statement-level confidence (“in our opinion”). Limited assurance is lower-confidence, negative-form (“nothing has come to our attention”). NZ CS 1 paragraph 25 sets limited assurance as the minimum for the mandatory GHG engagement. Contact’s Scope 3 is split: Category 11 (use of sold products) at reasonable, the remaining categories at limited.
Executive summary
- All four listed gentailers obtain independent third-party assurance over their FY2025 greenhouse-gas emissions disclosures. 100% assurance coverage of the sector.
- Two firms sign all four reports. Deloitte signs Genesis and Meridian, both as the Auditor-General’s appointee. EY signs Contact (engaged directly) and Mercury (as the Auditor-General’s appointee); the same EY partner, Matthew Cowie, signs both. Neither KPMG, PwC nor any non-Big-4 provider is engaged.
- 3 of 4 engagements are carried out by the Auditor-General (MEL, GNE, MCY). Genesis, Mercury and Meridian are mixed-ownership-model companies in which the Crown holds a majority, and their assurance reports state that under section 461ZH(3) of the Financial Markets Conduct Act 2013 the Auditor-General is their assurance practitioner. CEN engages its assurance provider directly.
- The assurance level gap on Scope 1 & 2 is the single most visible comparability dimension. 3 of 4 issuers (CEN, MEL, GNE) hold reasonable assurance on Scope 1 and 2. Mercury holds limited assurance across all three scopes.
- Scope 3 is at limited assurance for all four, with one exception. Contact’s largest Scope 3 category, Category 11 (use of sold products), is inside its reasonable-assurance opinion; its other Scope 3 categories are at limited. Every issuer discloses Scope 3 and has it assured; category coverage differs by issuer (see the companion methodology page).
- Standards cited converge. All four assurance reports cite NZ SAE 1 and ISAE (NZ) 3410; Mercury’s also cites ISAE (NZ) 3000 (Revised).
- Two key matters recur in the 2 reports that include key matters (CEN, MCY, both signed by EY): the spend-based method used for Scope 3 purchased goods and capital goods (inherent uncertainty), and the measurement of Scope 1 geothermal emissions. The Deloitte reports (Genesis, Meridian) report no key matters. All four opinions and conclusions are unmodified.
Section 1 — Who assures the gentailers
Two Big 4 firms, Deloitte and EY, carry out all four engagements. Three run through the Auditor-General; one is a direct engagement.
| Issuer | Provider firm | Appointment basis | Partner / signed |
|---|---|---|---|
CEN Contact Energy Limited | EY | Engaged directly by the issuer | Matthew Cowie · 18 August 2025p.38–41 |
MEL Meridian Energy Limited | Deloitte | Auditor-General (FMCA s461ZH(3)); firm carries out the work on the Auditor-General’s behalf | Anthony Smith · 26 August 2025p.52–54 |
GNE Genesis Energy Limited | Deloitte | Auditor-General (FMCA s461ZH(3)); firm carries out the work on the Auditor-General’s behalf | Silvio Bruinsma · 25 August 2025p.71–74 |
MCY Mercury NZ Limited | EY | Auditor-General (FMCA s461ZH(3)); firm carries out the work on the Auditor-General’s behalf | Matthew Cowie · 19 August 2025p.26–29 |
Reading: Genesis, Mercury and Meridian are mixed-ownership-model companies in which the Crown holds a majority, and public entities under the Public Audit Act 2001. Section 461ZH(3) of the Financial Markets Conduct Act 2013 (as replaced by the Financial Sector (Climate-related Disclosures and Other Matters) Amendment Act 2021, in force 27 October 2024) provides that for a climate reporting entity that is a public entity, only the Auditor-General (or a person who may act for the Auditor-General) may carry out the GHG assurance engagement. In each case the Auditor-General appointed a partner using the staff and resources of a private firm: Deloitte for Genesis and Meridian, EY for Mercury. Contact is not a public entity and engages EY directly. That is why EY appears under both appointment paths.
Section 2 — Assurance standards cited
The standards each assurance report states the engagement was conducted under.
| Issuer | Standard(s) cited |
|---|---|
| CEN | NZ SAE 1 and ISAE (NZ) 3410p.38–41 |
| MEL | NZ SAE 1 and ISAE (NZ) 3410p.52–54 |
| GNE | NZ SAE 1 (mandatory GHG disclosures) and ISAE (NZ) 3410p.71–74 |
| MCY | NZ SAE 1, ISAE (NZ) 3000 (Revised) and ISAE (NZ) 3410p.26–29 |
Reading: for FY2025 all four reports name NZ SAE 1 together with ISAE (NZ) 3410, so the standards cited no longer separate the issuers. What still differs is the level of assurance obtained and which disclosures sit inside the assured perimeter (Section 3).
Section 3 — Assurance level and scope
Two axes distinguish assurance engagements: the level (limited vs reasonable) and the scope (which disclosures sit inside the assured perimeter). The level gap on Scope 1 & 2 is the single most visible comparability dimension across the sector.
| Issuer | Level | Scope of engagement |
|---|---|---|
| CEN | Reasonable (S1&2) Reasonable (Scope 1, Scope 2 location-based, and Scope 3 Category 11 use of sold products); Limited (rest of Scope 3) | Gross Scope 1, Scope 2 (location-based) and Scope 3 emissions (Climate Statement p.30), related additional GHG disclosures (pp.28–29) and methods, assumptions and estimation uncertainty (pp.31–32). The rest of the Climate Statement (pp.1–27, 33–37) is outside the engagement.p.38–41 |
| MEL | Reasonable (S1&2) Reasonable (Scope 1 & 2); Limited (Scope 3) | Gross Scope 1, Scope 2 (location-based) and Scope 3 emissions (p.34) and the related NZ CS 1 para 24 and NZ CS 3 paras 52–54 disclosures (p.33 and Appendix B). Deloitte separately assured the GHG Emissions Inventory Report under ISAE (NZ) 3410 (separate limited assurance report).p.52–54 |
| GNE | Reasonable (S1&2) Reasonable (Scope 1 & 2); Limited (Scope 3) | Mandatory GHG disclosures in the Group Climate Statement (Scope 1, Scope 2 location-based, Scope 3) plus, as additional disclosures, the GHG Inventory Report in Appendix II — reasonable for Scope 1 & 2 and limited for Scope 3 in both.p.71–74 |
| MCY | Limited Limited (Scope 1, 2 and 3) | Scope 1, Scope 2 (location-based) and Scope 3 gross emissions; GHG Protocol compliance statement; consolidation approach; emission factors & GWP sources; exclusions; methods and uncertainty; base-year restatements — plus, by agreement, the other NZ CS disclosures on pp.1–24 of the Climate Statement that are not subject to mandatory assurance.p.26–29 |
Section 4 — Matters of emphasis, key matters and qualifications
No issuer in the sector received a modified (qualified, adverse or disclaimer) assurance report for FY25. The two EY reports (Contact, Mercury) include key matters, and the same two themes appear in both; the two Deloitte reports (Genesis, Meridian) report none.
Unmodified reasonable-assurance opinion and unmodified limited-assurance conclusion. Two key matters: (i) spend-based Scope 3 purchased goods & services and capital goods (~8% of total emissions, ~25% of Scope 3; emission-factor provider changed in FY25); (ii) Scope 1 geothermal emissions (~19% of total emissions). Other matter: FY18 base-year comparatives not assured.p.38–41
Unmodified reasonable-assurance opinion (Scope 1 & 2) and unmodified limited-assurance conclusion (Scope 3). No key matters reported. Other matter: FY21, FY23 and FY24 comparatives were not assured under NZ SAE 1.p.52–54
Unmodified reasonable-assurance opinion (Scope 1 & 2) and unmodified limited-assurance conclusion (Scope 3). No key matters reported. Other matter: FY20–FY24 comparatives were not assured under NZ SAE 1 (FY24 was assured by Deloitte under ISAE (NZ) 3410; FY20–FY23 by another provider).p.71–74
Unmodified limited-assurance conclusion. Two key matters: (i) spend-based Scope 3 purchased goods & services and capital goods (~19% of total emissions, ~39% of Scope 3); (ii) Scope 1 geothermal emissions (~50% of total emissions), calculated with internally derived unique emission factors. Other matter: restated FY22–FY24 Scope 3 Categories 1 and 2 were not assured.p.26–29
Recurring theme 1 — Scope 3 spend-based methods. Both EY reports make Scope 3 categories 1 (purchased goods & services) and 2 (capital goods), measured with spend-based factors, a key matter: about 8% of Contact’s total emissions and 19% of Mercury’s. Both note that the method carries inherent uncertainty and that future changes in method or assumptions could lead to material restatements. Genesis and Meridian also report these categories, but their Deloitte reports raise no key matters.
Recurring theme 2 — Geothermal emissions calculation. The two geothermal generators make Scope 1 geothermal emissions a key matter: about 19% of Contact’s total emissions and about 50% of Mercury’s. Emissions are calculated from steam-flow measurements the issuer makes itself and plant-specific emission factors based on third-party steam-sample testing. Mercury calculates its unique emission factors internally and has them externally assured when a plant’s steam properties deviate more than 5% from the prior year.
Section 5 — Reading across: what the sector says about NZ SAE 1 implementation
The NZ-listed gentailer set is arguably the most compliance-ready slice of the New Zealand Climate Reporting Entity universe: regulated, majority Crown-owned for three of four, with long-standing sustainability-reporting histories and generation portfolios that are natural focal points for climate disclosure. If NZ SAE 1 is not being applied cleanly here, it is not being applied cleanly anywhere.
Two observations follow.
First: the step from limited to reasonable assurance on Scope 1 and 2 has largely happened: three of four issuers have made the move, and Mercury has not. A reader should expect Mercury to explain its assurance level, and the remaining difference is now a choice by one issuer rather than a sector norm.
Second: Scope 3 assurance is at the limited level everywhere except Contact’s Category 11. The comparability problem this creates is unlikely to resolve through assurance alone — it resolves through Scope 3 methodology convergence. An assurance report can verify that a spend-based estimate has been prepared in accordance with the stated methodology, but it cannot fix the fact that two issuers using two spend-based methodologies produce two numbers that are not directly comparable. This is a standards-setting question, not an assurance-market question.
Methodology and sources
Every assurance finding in this report (provider, appointment route, partner, level by scope, standards, key matters and other matters) was re-checked on 17 October 2026 against the independent assurance report in each issuer’s FY2025 climate statement listed below. Page numbers are PDF page numbers of that document. The legal basis for the Auditor-General route was checked against section 461ZH of the Financial Markets Conduct Act 2013 on legislation.govt.nz.
- CEN — Contact Energy Climate Statement 2025 (year ended 30 June 2025)(42 pp · 1 July 2024 – 30 June 2025)
- MEL — MEL Climate-related Disclosures FY2025(54 pp · 1 July 2024 – 30 June 2025 (Year 7 of climate reporting))
- GNE — GNE Climate-related Disclosures FY2025(79 pp · 1 July 2024 – 30 June 2025)
- MCY — MCY Climate Statement FY2025(30 pp · 1 July 2024 – 30 June 2025)
Companion page with full methodology comparison (including non-assurance fields): NZ Gentailer Climate-Disclosure Methodology Comparison. Assurance facts verified: 2026-10-17. Other methodology fields on the companion page were extracted on 2026-04-20 and, apart from Contact’s, have not been re-verified.
For users of climate statements
- Treat limited and reasonable assurance as materially different reliance levels. A reasonable-assurance Scope 1 figure can be relied on at the same level as an audited financial number. A limited-assurance figure cannot.
- Ask what is inside the assured perimeter, not just the level. Contact’s Scope 3 is split between reasonable (Category 11) and limited (other categories); Mercury’s limited engagement also covers the other NZ CS disclosures in its climate statement; Genesis and Meridian extend assurance to their separate GHG inventory reports. The scope statement in the assurance report is load-bearing.
- Expect Scope 3 restatements over the next two reporting cycles. As other CREs complete the materiality assessments Mercury completed in FY25, restatements of prior years will continue. Year-over-year comparisons that span a restatement require re-baselining.
- Watch the key-matters language. Recurring themes across the sector (spend-based Scope 3; geothermal emission factors) are not issuer-specific concerns — they are sector-wide methodology fragilities that NZ SAE 1 will not resolve on its own.
Policy implications for GHG assurance requirements
The assurance market for NZ gentailer GHG disclosures is effectively formed. Two Big 4 firms carry out every engagement; three of four run through the Auditor-General. What remains open is the shape of what the assurance requirements ask for beyond the limited-assurance minimum. Three propositions, in order of materiality:
- Reasonable assurance on Scope 1 and 2 should become the default for CREs within one to two reporting cycles. Three of the four gentailers are already there. A named transition date removes ambiguity and prevents the issuer-by-issuer divergence this report documents from becoming permanent.
- Scope 3 assurance expectations need to be standardised by category, not in aggregate. Limited assurance on “Scope 3 gross emissions” means very different things when Scope 3 category coverage differs between issuers (Contact reports 10 of the 15 categories), and when one issuer assures a single category at a higher level than the rest. A category-level assurance scope disclosure would surface this today without waiting for NZ SAE 1 amendments.
- The key matters raised in the EY reports should be elevated to standard-level guidance, not left to preparer discretion. Spend-based Scope 3 uncertainty and internally-calculated geothermal emission factors are not exceptions; spend-based Scope 3 methods are used across the sector, and both geothermal generators were flagged. Named guidance on both would move the conversation from “is this acceptable?” to “is this being applied consistently?”
Data sourced from publicly available records. Our datasets may not be complete. Automated analysis can produce errors. If you believe any data on this page is incorrect, please contact us at hello@nzxplorer.co.nz. For informational purposes only. Not investment advice.