BFG Annual Shareholders Meeting Results 07 September 2023
07 September 2023
Results of Burger Fuel Group Limited
At Burger Fuel Group Limited’s shareholder meeting, held on-line via Zoom, on the
7th September 2023 at 11.00am, shareholders were asked to vote on two resolutions, which were all
supported by the Board.
As required by NZX Listing Rule 6.1, all voting was conducted by a poll.
The resolutions passed by shareholders were:
• That Josef Roberts be re-elected as a director of BFG.
• That the Board be authorised to fix the auditor’s remuneration for the ensuing year.
Detail of the total number of votes cast in person or by a proxy holder are:
Resolution For Against Abstain
That Josef Roberts be re-elected as a director of
BFG.
34,128,722
98.12%
153,453
0.44%
500,869
1.44%
That the Board be authorised to fix the auditor’s
remuneration for the ensuing year.
34,461,742
99.08%
312,400
0.90%
8,902
0.02%
Special Resolution For Against Abstain
N/A N/A N/A
Authority for this announcement
Name of person authorised to make this
announcement
Mark Piet
CFO / Company Secretary
Contact person for this announcement Mark Piet
Contact phone number 021 453 333
Contact email address Mark.Piet@Burgerfuel.com
Date of release through MAP 07/09/2023
---
1
BURGER FUEL GROUP LIMITED
Annual Shareholders Meeting of BURGER FUEL GROUP LIMITED.
To be held online via Zoom on
Thursday 07 September 2023 at 11.00 am.
Chairman's Address,
Results for the Year to 31 March 2023.
BurgerFuel Group (unaudited) Total System Sales (all three brands, all regions) increased by
12.77% to $106.2M on the same period last year.
In FY23 the Group Revenue increased 14.5% to $24M and the Net Profit after tax for the
period was $900,418 which was a 56.3% increase on the previous year.
This result reflects a less disrupted year compared to the previous two years and total system
sales are getting back to pre-Covid levels. The FY23 year however was very challenging.
The hospitality sector was hit hard by staff shortages and increased supply chain costs. These
costs continue to rise. However, given these circumstances we believe the Group achieved
a solid performance and a meaningful profit increase for the year.
The Group had strong store sales in FY23 which were bolstered by the opening of the
BurgerFuel Cambridge & Rolleston stores in May and October 2022 respectively. We also
introduced delivery sales for Winner Winner and Shake Out, and we are benchmarking
against reduced trading days in FY22, when the stores were closed due to Covid (August &
September 2021). The CBD stores also had improved sales due to office workers returning to
the city centres. The trend of people returning to work in central city offices seems to be
continuing, to the benefit of our city stores.
We are hopeful that the sales increase will continue into FY24 with the introduction of online
delivery options for BurgerFuel being trialled across selected stores in the BurgerFuel system.
However, we are conscious of the fact that the economic environment remains challenging,
and this will likely impact sales. We are starting to see some softening of sales in recent weeks.
Rising costs in both ingredients and labour have meant that we have had to increase prices
and we cannot be sure what impact this will ultimately have on customer purchases.
As at 31 March 2023 there were 60 BurgerFuel restaurants operating in NZ and 7 operating in
the Middle East excluding third party delivery only “dark kitchens”, operating in the UAE.
These third-party dark kitchens in the UAE are however under review as these particular
facilities are overwhelmed with other brands, and it is difficult to maintain a quality standard
that is synonymous with the BurgerFuel brand in New Zealand. This is a great concept to
generate sales but maintaining quality and protecting the brand is of the upmost
importance.
2
General Review
At this stage the Group Performance over the next 12 months remains uncertain with the
current worsening economic conditions, but the recent pockets of sales growth are
promising, as is the proposed trial of the delivery service for select BurgerFuel outlets.
Regarding franchise opportunities and growth in new stores in FY24, it is unclear if FY24 will
yield any potential suitable franchisees for new locations, due to the current economic
conditions with construction, operating and financing costs all increasing significantly in the
last 12 months. Accordingly, the group is considering using some of its cash reserves to
finance franchisees into new sites, so that we may continue to grow throughout New
Zealand. This will be evaluated in the coming months.
Once again the past year has confirmed BurgerFuel’s robustness as a well-established brand
within New Zealand and we are aiming to at least maintain consumer demand (sales) in
FY24, despite increased prices.
In summary, the Group’s future financial results will depend on many factors including the on-
going rising costs, both in the supply chain and labour, and the overall economic conditions
that New Zealand is clearly facing. We can see from the other listed companies that fast
food is very challenging at present, with the absorption of rising costs coupled with price
increases. It remains to be seen if these factors will impact customer purchases, by both
volume of transactions, as well as the average ticket price of transactions.
At this stage we are quite pleased with the progress of the Shake Out brand and hopefully
some of you have managed to try this faster, simpler burger concept. If not, and you are in
Auckland, you can visit either the Commercial Bay or Smales Farm outlets.
Our Winner Winner chicken concept has proven to be more complex to operate then we
ultimately want and accordingly we are modifying and simplifying this concept so that any
future Winner Winner stores will be in a more streamlined format. We hope to trial this new
and simpler format, sometime later in FY25.
Whilst we do have a healthy balance sheet and sufficient cash reserves, we are also mindful
of uncertain trading conditions and the need to fund growth by way of financial assistance
on greenfield sites and (or) any other opportunities that may arise. Over the last few years,
we thought it prudent to let the cash reserves build up to get us through the uncertain Covid
times. There are still significant economic headwinds ahead and we want to retain healthy
cash reserves for the foreseeable future.
Having said that, if cash is not required for growth and investment in the future, the board will
review options and consider potentially distributing some of the cash to shareholders in the
most tax efficient manner, however this is yet to be determined.
That concludes my speech for today. Thank you, I will return to address you all later in the
meeting, but for now, I would like to hand you over to Josef Roberts our Chief Executive.
3
Chief Executive’s Address,
Good morning, everyone and welcome to our 16th AGM. As Peter noted FY23 was another
busy and challenging year for the BurgerFuel Group, as it was for the entire hospitality and
fast-food sector.
To begin with, I would like to give you an overview of the events that made up our reported
results in FY23, as well as update you on the current year.
FY23 had less disruptions than the previous Covid years, but with the country going into the
early stages of a recession, it was a year of navigating through the high inflation levels,
increased labour costs and labour shortages. This situation continues with rising costs both
globally and locally and there doesn’t seem to be any signs of this letting up. However, as
Peter noted, despite the turbulence and increased costs, we were able to deliver a 56%
increase in profit on the previous year.
Sales were strong in FY23 and are more or less back to pre-Covid levels, but again, the
increased sales over the previous year were helped with the opening of two new BurgerFuel
stores in FY23, and also benchmarking against a Covid disrupted FY22.
We did encounter floods and weather havoc in the last months of the financial year. All of
these events impact costs with disruption, sometimes store closures and certainly supply
chain price increases that occur, due to a shortage of certain ingredients from time to time.
There is no doubt, that the radical weather patterns both globally and locally will continue to
negatively impact costs going forward. Put it this way, nothing is getting cheaper, costs are
only rising.
Running a restaurant chain in these times remains challenging, both at an existing store
operational level, as well as endeavouring to grow the BurgerFuel brand in new locations. In
itself, BurgerFuel is reaching maturity, as to the number of potential outlets available in New
Zealand. Attracting new franchisees for new greenfield sites is proving difficult due to higher
interest rates, increased build and operating costs, staffing issues and the uncertain times
ahead.
We have certainly invested in marketing potential new locations, and we are always
endeavouring to locate new operators, but they are not easy to find in this economic
environment. As well, BurgerFuel has always prided itself on attracting high quality
franchisees who properly represent our brand and generally stay the course of time. We
don’t just accept anyone as a franchisee, and that policy won’t be changing, because we
have learnt that short-term operator decisions, only lead to longer term problems.
BurgerFuel New Zealand
The BurgerFuel New Zealand business remains strong and sustainable. We have been well
supported by our customers, staff, and franchisees.
We currently have 61 BurgerFuel stores operating in New Zealand, due to the opening of the
new BurgerFuel Dunedin store in April 2023. This store has been well received by students and
other locals who were waiting patiently for us to get there. To date Dunedin is performing
really well.
4
We are also pleased to announce that BurgerFuel has been trialling online delivery through
third party aggregators and we expect this to continue, so that our product should be
available for delivery through most stores by Christmas. We have been cautious to enter
delivery as we do see potential issues with this model. However, to date we have seen good
sales growth with participating stores, and generally, we have been satisfied with the quality
of the product being delivered, but we will monitor this closely.
We still pride ourselves on the customer journey and instore experience, because there is
nothing like a BurgerFuel burger, hot off the grill. But delivery is now a fact of life, especially
following Covid, and this adds to the convenience factor for those of our customers who
would like to order this way and are prepared to pay for the service.
Despite the turbulence with the pandemic, weather bombs and rising costs, we are always
innovating at BurgerFuel to both fulfil our customers’ brand and product expectations, as
well as to increase our market share.
Some of you may have seen us on Country Calendar quite recently, helping to utilise venison
in the South Island and creating the amazing venison burger we called the “Wild Heart”. This
was a collaboration about conservation as well as rescuing quality food that would
otherwise go to waste. We paired the venison burger with our very own cherry cola made
from rescued cherries from the South Island. We also undertook what we term a 360-degree
project where we rescued wasted bread to make beer (our very own LagerFuel), to turn it
back into flour, to make bread again – in the form of our buns. These innovations are all
about supporting local, reducing food waste, and moving towards a better and more
sustainable way of doing things. There is a lot of food wasted on this planet and we don’t
want to be part of this culture for any longer than is necessary. Therefore, we must look much
harder at how we source our food and where it comes from.
At BurgerFuel, we are always developing innovative, workable ideas that showcase our
brand, and meet our commitment to a lower carbon footprint and better long-term
sustainability.
BurgerFuel has always been ahead of the curve on such things as packaging and our
general environmental standpoint. Our packaging material is now almost 100%
compostable. Whilst there is still a lot more work to do in New Zealand from third party
suppliers, in terms of ensuring that all packaging ends up in the right place for composting,
we are at least moving in the right direction. In summary there are always things happening
at BFHQ to keep the brand moving ahead. Innovation is at the core of everything we do.
There is another constant battle going on, and that is against the SAS – or software as a
service business model – or simply put, the ticket clipping. We are continually guarding
against these fee-based subscription models that creep into the business if we are not
careful. On that note, we are investing a lot more into Information Technology, simply to stay
in control of our business and avoid paying others to undertake services that we can better
undertake ourselves.
Many companies would like to talk directly to our customers or gain access to them in some
way, and we are determined not to let that become the standard. This is a challenging and
on-going battle, but one we are well advanced in, especially with the introduction of our
5
own online ordering platform, a system that has been entirely developed in house and is
currently being rolled out throughout New Zealand. Our new loyalty programme will follow
soon after.
I.T is becoming an increasingly expensive area, but one that every business simply must invest
in, and we are no exception. We have millions of transactions occurring annually and we
need to be in control of these, whilst ensuring they are smooth and trouble free for our
customers.
These days the business of making hamburgers is a lot more than just that. We must
constantly innovate and develop better and faster systems to ensure that we stay ahead of
the curve, and remain a place that customers want to visit. I am very proud of the efforts
that all of our team at HQ undertake on a daily basis, to deliver the best standout customer
experience we can.
Our franchisees are obviously also a huge part of this because without them and their teams
all working on a daily basis to a synchronised, systematic approach, we simply would not be
here today. BurgerFuel is a well-developed machine, but it requires constant updating and
innovation and that will never stop.
Winner Winner New Zealand
Winner Winner total sales increased by 33.5%. This was due to the introduction of delivery
services and the benching against reduced sales in FY22. In May 2023 we decided to close
our company owned Winner Winner store in Takapuna, Auckland. This site opened during
Covid and suffered as a result. It never really performed well, and its closure has reduced the
ongoing losses in that location. Winner Winner is a great brand, but growing a new brand in
the last few Covid years has proven to be challenging.
We learnt from this restaurant and as a result we are reworking our Winner Winner offer, to
reduce complexity and ultimately make the brand more scalable. As Peter mentioned a
new, faster, more refined and simplified Winner Winner format is on the cards, and
depending on the economic environment, we will hopefully open this new model later in FY
25.
Shake Out New Zealand
Shake Out total store sales increased by 61.6% in FY23 due mainly to the introduction of delivery
services in April 2022 and the opening of our company owned Shake Out store in the
Commercial Bay precinct, downtown Auckland, in November 2022.
This store is performing quite well and as expected but has had a few disruptions since opening
with the Christmas period and then the extreme weather events occurring in early 2023. This
site rises and falls off the pedestrian traffic in the Commercial Bay precinct, on a weekly basis.
There is no doubt that the CBDs in all centres have had their challenges following more staff
working from home, as well as unforeseen weather bombs, but as Peter noted, it appears that
slowly the trend is changing and more people are coming back to work in the CBD again,
including students.
6
We have just opened a Shake Out delivery only “dark kitchen” in Glendene, Auckland to test
the market for this model. We have a lot of experience with dark kitchens from our operations
in the Middle East. It’s a model that we think can work well in New Zealand, if managed
properly, but equally we also know people ultimately like to visit our restaurants. Hopefully we
can get the balance between these two options, spot on here in NZ, as the demand for
delivery continues.
It's important to remember that BurgerFuel's first 10 years were very difficult too, but now look
at its success. Both WW & SO have had a couple of misfires, and as a Franchisor we are
learning from those, but risks will have to be taken going forward to build and establish these
new brands. Location strategy is often difficult to get right in the early years.
For FY23 the two new brands represented 9.0% of total NZ sales, which although in itself is not
huge, it is important to remember the three years we have just come out of with the Covid
disruptions. I’m hoping we can now get a clear run at building up Shake Out.
BurgerFuel Middle East
In April 2022 we appointed a new Master Licensee for the entire region to one company that
assumes responsibility for the appointment and operations of individual stores and regional
franchisees. This is effectively a Development Agent (DA) Agreement structure.
Under the DA Agreement BFG will receive a share of royalties generated from BurgerFuel
sales in the region and each new store will be DA owned or franchised under the terms of
the agreement. The DA will be responsible for site selection and store construction as well as
training and day to day operations. As previously advised, the Group incurred costs in FY23 in
relation to setting up this new DA structure with a view to rebuilding the brand in the MENA
region over future years. I personally have been very involved in the re-development of the
Middle East. The reason we decided to give it another go up there after Covid is because
the brand was successful there some years ago, and it is still well known by local consumers.
The BurgerFuel store in the Dubai World Trade Centre is currently undergoing a full refit, which
will reflect an updated store design. It is intended that this new look store will attract potential
franchisees within the region and allow further franchising by the DA. The new look will also
assist us in providing an updated image here in our New Zealand stores, many of which are
coming up for refits.
The future of MENA will be entirely dependent on the success of the new DA structure. Whilst
BFG’s percentage share of royalties will be lower than in previous years, our operational
involvement and costs will also be on a reduced basis.
The Middle East sales are down due to the previous UAE licence holder exiting the brand and
closing 3 stores. Saudi Arabia also closed 2 stores in FY23 and 2 stores in FY24 and now have 4
stores operating in this region. There are also several “dark kitchens” operating in Dubai, which
is a common business model in this region due to the extreme temperatures, but as Peter
noted, these formats are not without their issues and quickly degrade the product quality if
they are not tightly managed. We expect that eventually having the “dark kitchens’ managed
under the DA structure as franchised units, could work very well.
7
BFG earnings from the Middle East have been diminishing for some years, and the Group
doesn’t anticipate generating any income from the Middle East until FY25 and even then,
earnings will be modest until (and only if) that region can grow. However, unlike New Zealand
where growth potential is very limited, the Middle East is really booming in parts, especially
Saudi Arabia where younger populations are abundant and there is a real buoyancy that
simply does not exist here in NZ. This is why we have made the decision to keep going in this
part of the world.
Summary
In summary, it has been a very lumpy few years following Covid and now it is clear that we
are in a recession with household debt at its highest levels in years and an economy that is
weak and looks likely to stay that way for a while yet. Globally, there are many issues the
world is facing and that affect us, here in New Zealand, on a daily basis. These times more
than ever mean that we must protect our customers, as well as our franchisee margins.
Fast food is not an easy industry to be in right now, it’s very hands on, but rewarding as well.
Most people love a good feed at BurgerFuel, and over the years we have built a household
brand in New Zealand. It’s important that we can keep innovating and investing in better
and more sustainable production, finding more efficient ways of doing things and of course
building on the many layers of marketing that we have undertaken over the years. It’s a
combination of all these factors and more that will ensure our survival and growth.
It is for this reason that we are also focused on the new brands and why we must give them
the chance to develop and grow like we did BurgerFuel. Our Shake Out brand is also a great
concept and over time I hope we will see that move ahead. Winner Winner has both hot
and cold spots, it is a long-term project that requires more development, but we intend to
persevere with it.
So, what does our future look like? Well, we are not immune to the problems our listed (and
unlisted) competitors face with rising costs and a constant need to pass those costs on to the
customers. We can only absorb so much ourselves before prices have to rise.
It seems to me that the costs to produce any food products in New Zealand, will continue to
rise. Recently we are seeing established hospitality industry outlets and even chains go into
liquidation. The Wishbone chain is an example of a significant and well-established business
that I respected, fall on hard times. This very recent failure reflects the difficulty of both
maintaining sales and managing growing costs, even in well established brands. There is no
doubt that having a strong balance sheet with little, or no debt has been comforting in these
past years of constant uncertainty.
In terms of acquisitions, we are always looking, but at this stage, we would not want to buy
turnover and potentially a whole lot more problems, without certainty of growth, and at
present growth is very hard to obtain here in New Zealand. We will simply have to see where
things go in the next 12-24 months and focus on maintaining what we have and growing
where we can, both at existing store level and numerically if that is possible, with the right
opportunities.
During the past year once again there has not been a great deal to communicate with you
about. Our 6 monthly updates by way of full and half year announcements contain all
relevant shareholder information. As well as our AGMs. That said, we will of course continue
8
to provide updates on any significant or material events that occur outside of these reports.
But for now, its steady as we go, let’s keep the wheels on, keep developing the business and
most of all maintaining, protecting, and growing our customer base.
That concludes my address today. I would like to thank you and all of our shareholders for
your continued involvement and support. I also wish to thank our many stakeholders,
suppliers and others that work with us each day. I do once again wish to give a big shout out
to our team at the BurgerFuel Head Office, all our in-store staff, and our franchisees. There
are around 1,100 people employed within the BurgerFuel system in New Zealand and we are
really proud of this home grown and much admired brand, that we have created.
Of course, finally I wish to thank those of you that dialled in to our AGM today. As I like to ask
each year at these meetings “when was the last time you visited a BurgerFuel? Or a Winner
Winner or a Shake Out?” Well, if there is one near you – do pop in, order a meal and spread
the word.
Thank you all for your attendance today. I will now hand you back to our Chairman Peter
Brook to continue the proceedings.
Chairman of the Board to close address to shareholders.
Thank you, Josef, and on behalf of the Board, I wish to thank all employees, franchisees, and
other business partners for their efforts. I would also like to thank my Board colleagues for their
support and the work that they have performed during the year.
Finally, the Directors would like to thank all shareholders for their ongoing support. We look
forward to continuing our work to support management and direct the business for the year
ahead.
Data sourced from publicly available filings. Our datasets may not be complete. Automated analysis can produce errors. If you believe any data on this page is incorrect, please contact us at hello@nzxplorer.co.nz. For informational purposes only. Not investment advice.
Other issuers discussed similar conditions around this time
Matched by meaning across NZX announcement text, not keywords — based on our semantic index of announcement bodies.
- MFB — My Food Bag Group Limited: Results of 2023 Annual Meeting2023-08-17
“Meeting Results Announcement 17 August 2023 NZX/ASX Code: MFB Results of My Food Bag Group Limited Annual Shareholders' Meeting At My Food Bag Group Limited’s annual shareholder meeting, held in Auckland and online today, shareholders were asked to vote on four resolutions,…”
- BPG — Black Pearl Group Limited: Meeting Results Announcement2023-09-04
“Blackpearl Group | Level 1 60 Cuba Street Wellington 6011 | New Zealand hello@blackpearlgroup.com | +64 480 39390 4 September 2023 Meeting Results Announcement Black Pearl Group Limited (NZX:BPG) advises that at its Annual Meeting of Shareholders held today, shareholder…”
- FBU — Fletcher Building: Results of 2023 Annual Shareholders Meeting2023-10-27
“Meeting Results Announcement Fletcher Building Limited, Private Bag 92114, Auckland 1142, 810 Great South Road, Penrose, Auckland 1061, New Zealand 27 October 2023 Results of Fletcher Building Limited 2023 Annual Shareholders’ Meeting At Fletcher Building Limited’s 20…”