Whale Trading Patterns: Holding Period Analysis

Q: What is the optimal holding period for substantial shareholders?

Based on 1000 trades, the most common holding period among profitable trades is 1-2 years with a 62.0% win rate and 16.2% average return.

Q: Do winning whales hold longer than losing whales?

Yes. Winning substantial shareholders hold for an average of 556 days (1.5 years), while losers exit after 449 days (1.2 years).

Q: What is the overall win rate for substantial shareholders on NZX?

Substantial shareholders have a 43.1% win rate across 1000 tracked positions, with winners averaging 52.8% returns.

NZXplorer

NZXplorer

Portfolio

Get NZX governance insights in your inbox

Weekly digest of board changes, insider trades, and market signals. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Whale Trading Patterns: Holding Periods & Win Rates | NZXplorer

Whale Tracker/

Patterns & Insights

What patterns appear in winning vs. losing positions? Discover patterns in holding periods, sectors, and timing.

Common Holding Period

1-2 years

Highest win rate: 62.0%

121 positions • $1742.8M total P&L

Best Returns Timeframe

3+ years

Avg return: +51.2%

107 positions tracked

Winner vs Loser

Winners hold for:

556 days

Losers hold for:

449 days

Win Rate by Holding Period

Does holding longer lead to better returns? Analyze win rates across different timeframes.

Holding Period	Positions	Win Rate	Avg Return	Total P&L
0-90 days	393	26.7%	+1.0%	+$212.9M
91-180 days	136	52.2%	+32.6%	+$1670.0M
181-365 days (6m-1y)	150	51.3%	+1.8%	$-127.7M
1-2 years	121	62.0%🏆	+16.2%	+$1742.8M
2-3 years	92	48.9%	+12.7%	+$2533.0M
3+ years	107	53.3%

Profitable Trades Profile

Total Winners

431

Avg Holding Period

556 days

(1.5 years)

Avg Return

+52.8%

Pattern: Profitable positions in this dataset tended to have longer holding periods with +53% average returns.

Losing Trades Profile

Total Losers

398

Avg Holding Period

449 days

(1.2 years)

Avg Return

-22.1%

Pattern: Losing positions are held for shorter periods on average, suggesting quick exits from declining positions.

Sector Holding Patterns

Do certain sectors show different holding period patterns historically?

Sector	Positions	Avg Holding	Win Rate
Energy	7	407 days (1.1 yrs)	71.4%
Utilities	60	400 days (1.1 yrs)	51.7%
Information Technology	72	407 days (1.1 yrs)	51.4%
Consumer Discretionary	94	696 days (1.9 yrs)	47.9%
Financials	72	462 days (1.3 yrs)	47.2%
Communication Services	135	395 days (1.1 yrs)	46.7%
Real Estate	125	380 days (1.0 yrs)	44.0%

Key Takeaways

Optimal Holding: The 1-2 years timeframe shows the highest win rate at 62%
Best Returns: Maximum average returns occur in the 3+ years period (+51%)
Hold Time Matters: Winners hold for an average of 556 days compared to 449 days for losers (+107 day difference)
Sector Variations: Different sectors show different optimal holding patterns, with Energy showing the highest win rate

Note: These patterns are based on historical substantial shareholder disclosures (5%+ stakes). Past performance does not guarantee future results. Individual circumstances vary significantly.

Disclaimer

P&L figures are estimates, not actual cost basis. Gains and losses are calculated using the stock price on the date a holder first crossed the 5% substantial shareholder disclosure threshold, multiplied by their latest reported share count. Actual acquisition costs may differ significantly as shares are typically accumulated over time at various prices.

Data sourced from NZX disclosures. Our datasets may not be complete and we are continuously updating and adding more data to the platform.

This analysis is provided for informational and educational purposes only. Nothing on this page constitutes financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Always conduct your own research and consult with qualified professionals before making any investment decisions.

Data sourced from publicly available NZX disclosures. Our datasets may not be complete. Automated analysis can produce errors. If you believe any data on this page is incorrect, please contact us at hello@nzxplorer.co.nz. Past performance does not indicate future results. For informational purposes only. Not investment advice.